Tuesday, March 20, 2018

An interpretation of medical report of the death of former Prime Minister Shri Lal Bahadur Shastri




The death of former Prime Minister Shri Lal Bahadur Shastri, who passed away in Tashkent, then the Soviet Union on January 11, 1966 has always been surrounded by mystery and there are several conspiracy theories about his death.

Now 52 years after his death, the medical report of his death was revealed by the Govt. in reply to an RTI filed on 24.12.2017. The RTI had asked for information on the true cause/s of the death of the prime minister and asked for a certified copy of the postmortem conducted in the USSR/India. This information was provided in a reply dated 19.1.2018. The report is available at:(http://www.republicworld.com/india-news/general-news/government-of-india-reveals-the-exact-cause-of-death-of-former-prime-minister-lal-bahadur-shastri.

As per the medical report appended with the statement made by the then Minister of External Affairs in 1966, death of Shri Lal Bahadur Shastri occurred because of an acute attack of ‘Infarctmiocardia’.

I was asked by the media to comment on this report. I also spoke to top arrhythmia experts, who said that we have never used KCl in India. But, on searching PubMed, I could find some literature on the use of KCl in cardiac arrest. May be this was the standard protocol followed by doctors in USSR at that point of time, which also correlates with scientific evidence.

Here is my interpretation (right of the box) of the medical report of the death of the former Prime Minister of India Shri Lal Bahadur Shastri.

During all the days of his stay in Tashkent, as well as on evening of January 1966, the Prime Minister of India Lal Bahadur Shastri felt well. He never complained about his health.

On the evening of 10th January 1966, the prime minister of India, Lal Bahadur Shastri as healthy and cheerful while he was attending a reception given by the chairman of the council of ministers of USSR,
AN Kosygin.

According to Dr RN Chugh, the doctor-attendant on the Prime Minister, who used to be always present at his side and thus had attended the reception, after return from the reception to his residence, Lal Bahadur Shastri was in normal health and was in a good mood and spoke over the telephone with his relatives in Delhi. He went to bed at about 12:30 midnight.

On the 11th of January, at about 1.20 in the morning, Messrs, Shay, Kapur and Sharma approached the Premier’s doctor who was in the room next to him and told him that the Prime Minister is feeling unwell.

He became unwell at 1.20 am
Dr R N Chugh at once approached the Prime Minister and found that the Prime Minister was sitting on his bed, coughing and was complaining of lack of breath. He was holding his chest with his hands and looking pale. The doctor found the pulse to be very fast and blood pressure was not registered. The heart beats were hardly audible.
This is a classical presentation of acute heart attack with left ventricular failure. Ventricular arrhythmia can be a possibility.
With the help of gentlemen mentioned above the doctor put the Prime Minster in the reclining position, gave him intramuscular injection of MEPHENTINE SULPHATE one ml (15 milligram) and 1 ml of MICOREN.
At that point of time, mephenteramine was a common drug given to raise the blood pressure. Micorena was a respiratory stimulant.
Within the next 3 minutes, PRIME MINISTER LB Shastri lost consciousness, the pulse disappeared, and breathing stopped and heart rate could not be heard.
It was a cardiac arrest.
Death occurred at 1.32 am in the morning of 11th January 1966.

Doctor R. N. Chugh had already began revival treatment by the method of indirect message of the heart and artificial respiration through the mouth by means of the air tube.

CPR was attempted.
The soviet doctor V G VERMENKO who had come there immediately on a call from Dr RN Chugh also took part in the treatment by revival procedure.

She found Prime Minister LB Shastri dead when she arrived. The pulse had stopped, the heart was silent, there was no breath and no corneal reflexes. The revival was continued further with the help of anti-….team of doctors which had arrived immediately on call. 


Indirect massage of the heart was done, in the left cavity mixture of potassium chloride with adrenaline and glucose

Here is some literature on the use of KCl in cardiac arrest.



Romain Jouffroy and BenoƮt Vivien. Antiarrhythmic drugs in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: is there a place for potassium chloride? Crit Care. 2017;21 144.

According to current guidelines, antiarrhythmic drugs should be administered during the metabolic phase of cardiac arrest, which is paradoxically the most unfavorable phase for their efficiency [1]. Twenty-five years ago, Beyersdorf et al. [2] observed that administration of a high-potassium solution could salvage cardiac arrest patients due to an irreversible VF in metabolic phase of cardiac arrest. Direct intravenous KCl injection was recently shown efficient to stop refractory VF in a patient under continuous ECLS: a few minutes after KCl administration, the heart recovered a hemodynamically efficient normal sinus rhythm [3].

1.       Soar J, Nolan JP, Bottiger BW, et al. European Resuscitation Council Guidelines for Resuscitation 2015: Section 3. Adult advanced life support. Resuscitation. 2015;95:100–47. doi: 10.1016/j.resuscitation.2015.07.016. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
2.       Beyersdorf F, Kirsch M, Buckberg GD, et al. Warm glutamate/aspartate enriched blood cardioplegic solution for perioperative sudden death. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 1992;104(4):1141–7.[PubMed]
3.       Jouffroy R, Lamhaut L, Philippe P, et al. A new approach for treatment of refractory ventricular fibrillation allowed by extra corporeal life support (ECLS)? Resuscitation. 2014;85(8):e118. doi: 10.1016/j.resuscitation.2013.12.038. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]

Metabolic phase is defined as greater than 10 minutes of pulselessness. It is primarily based upon post-resuscitative measures, including hypothermia therapy. If not quickly converted into a perfusing rhythm, patients in this phase generally do not survive.

Refractory cardiac arrest is defined as the absence of return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC) after 30 min of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR).

Jouffroy R, Lamhaut L, Philippe P, An K, Carli P, Vivien B. A new approach for treatment of refractory ventricular fibrillation allowed by extra corporeal life support (ECLS)? Resuscitation. 2014;85(8):e118.

A 50-year-old male with refractory ventricular fibrillation (VF) out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) was treated at home by a mobile intensive care unit team. Since ROSC was not achieved after 30 min of prehospital resuscitation despite 20 external shocks and 900 mg IV amiodarone, the patient was admitted to an ICU for implementation of ECLS (Cardiohelp Maquet©), which was started with an initial rate of 4 l min−1 (4000 rev min−1), resulting in a mean arterial blood pressure of 65 mmHg. However, VF persisted despite five additional shocks.  Since adequate tissue perfusion was ensured by ECLS, potassium chloride 3 g was injected intravenously in order to stop the VF. Less than 1 min later, the patient presented with a stable sinus cardiac rhythm, and progressively recovered spontaneously efficient circulatory function. Coronary angiography revealed an occlusion of the right coronary artery, which was treated by angioplasty and endovascular stent implementation. ECLS was removed on day 2 and the patient weaned from mechanical ventilation on day 6, and discharged on day 11 with a cerebral performance category (CPC) score of 2.

The use of potassium to treat persistent VF has been described during cardiothoracic surgery6 and in a pig model of cardiac arrest,7 but to the best of our knowledge, our case is the first to describe potassium administration to stop refractory VF, while effective tissue perfusion was ensured using ECLS. Further studies are required to evaluate the efficiency of this treatment for patients in refractory VF treated with ECLS.


1.         Le Guen, M., Nicolas-Robin, A., Carreira, S. et al. Extracorporeal life support following out-of-hospital refractory cardiac arrest. Crit Care. 2011; 15: R29.
2.         Cave, D.M., Gazmuri, R.J., Otto, C.W. et al. Part 7: CPR techniques and devices: 2010 American Heart Association Guidelines for Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation and Emergency Cardiovascular Care. Circulation. 2010; 122: S720–S728.
3.         Neumar, R.W., Otto, C.W., Link, M.S. et al. Part 8: adult advanced cardiovascular life support: 2010 American Heart Association Guidelines for Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation and Emergency Cardiovascular Care. Circulation. 2010; 122: S729–S767.
4.         Van Alem, A.P., Post, J., and Koster, R.W. VF recurrence: characteristics and patient outcome in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. Resuscitation. 2003; 5: 181–188.
5.         Liu, Y., Zhang, S.L., Duan, W.X. et al. The myocardial protective effects of a moderate-potassium blood cardioplegia in pediatric cardiac surgery: a randomized controlled trial. Ann Thorac Surg. 2012;94: 1295–1301.
6.         Watanabe, G., Yashiki, N., Tomita, S., and Yamaguchi, S. Potassium-induced cardiac resetting technique for persistent ventricular tachycardia and fibrillation after aortic declamping. Ann Thorac Surg. 2011; 91: 619–620.
7.         Lee, H.Y., Lee, B.K., Jeung, K.W. et al. Potassium induced cardiac standstill during conventional cardiopulmonary resuscitation in a pig model of prolonged ventricular fibrillation cardiac arrest: a feasibility study. Resuscitation. 2013; 84: 378–383.

Artificial respiration by means of the machines with the help of intubation tube was also attempted.
However, those measures yielded no results.


The following professors also took part in the entire treatment

UA ARIPOV
YK GORDAN
ON PAVLON
AR RAKHIMJANOY
MS THRSUM-KHOJAEVA
ZE UMMIDOVA



19.1.18
Praveen Kumar
PMO
Sd/-

RRTI /5510/2017/PMR
Rohit Chaudhury






Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA

Monday, March 19, 2018

No news story about any system of medicine should be published in media without first verifying from the experts



Ministry of Ayush recently published a reply to a news story titled "Ayurvedic Med Poses Life Threat" published in The Pune Mirror newspaper on 25th December, 2017.
The letter said that “the title of the news item was so generalized that it may lead to an overall distrust in the minds of the readers at large regarding the safety, efficacy and overall credibility of Ayurveda in general and Suvama Bhasma- an important Ayurvedic medicine in particular… It is pertinent to note that one bad example cannot be allowed to tarnish the credibility of the whole system of Ayurveda. In view of the above, 'The pune Mirror' may consider publishing a corrigendum *rand apology at the earliest to enlighten the readers and explain to this Ministry the basis of publishing the news in such an irresponsible manner, within two weeks of this communication failing which, the matter will be taken up with PTI and PIB. Also, the newspaper may abstain from publishing such derogatory reports which tarnish the credibility of time tested medicines”.
As per Vedic knowledge when the matter is converted into non-matter in the form of energy, it is used either as potentised drug in homoepathy or a bhasma in Ayurveda.
 During the processes of potentisation or trituration in homeopathy and bhasma formation by the process of homa in Ayurveda, when the matter converts  into non matter (non measurable), it changes its properties. It is non-measurable at this stage by any current investigational criteria. 
If any matter is detected, it indicates adulteration or inadequate trituration or potentisation.
There are regulators in all respective fields, as are experts. Hence, any complaint should be referred to them rather than addressing them in the media without any expertise in that field. 
No such news story should be allowed to be published in media  without first verifying facts or fact checking. It may not be the truth.
This is equally true for all systems of medicine.

Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA

Sunday, March 18, 2018

Depression among doctors is a growing problem: Genesis of depression




Dr KK Aggarwal


Mail Today recently featured a cover story of how mounting stress level due to work pressure is taking a toll on the mental health of doctors at All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), Delhi. Some of them are admitted in the psychiatric ward of the institute and are undergoing treatment, the story further said.

Depression among doctors is a growing problem and it is now increasingly being reported. According to a study published in JAMA (JAMA. 2015;314(22):2373-2383), between 20.9% and 43.2% of trainees screened positive for depression or depressive symptoms during residency.

As per quantum physics matter can be sequentially broken into atoms and then to subatomic particles (protons, electrons and neutrons), photons, quantum and wave. A photon is both a wave and a particle at the same time (wave particle duality). The human body is also a particle and a wave at the same time. In terms of science, this duality exists as a balance between sympathetic and parasympathetic states.

According to the Vedas, thoughts arise from our consciousness. Thoughts lead to action. Every action leads to a memory, which in turn leads to a desire. A cycle of action, memory and desire is subsequently set into motion. Fulfilled desires result in actions to realize that desire again or fulfil a new desire. Repeated fulfilment of desires leads to habits, addictions and behavior. Unfulfilled desires lead to anger, which can be expressive anger or suppressive anger.

Expressive anger (anger-out), or uncontrolled outbursts of anger, becomes evident as aggressive behavior and/or violence. Suppressive anger (anger-in), can be acute or chronic. Acute suppressed anger can manifest as acute heart attack, acute asthmatic or anxiety attack. While, chronic suppressed anger may lead to depression in due course of time.

Non fulfilment of desires, expectations and aspiration over a period of time therefore is the main cause of depression.

The desires are need-based. Human behaviour is governed by needs, which can be at the level of physical body, mind, intellect, ego or the soul. These needs result in desires, expectations and aspirations.

These can be in the form of respect, recognition and prestige, once the basic physical needs of food, clothing etc. are satisfied.

The feeling of discontent may also be a result of humiliation from seniors/faculty, exam pattern, hurt ego (by patients and/or their families), the daily trauma of dealing with sickness/death, long gruelling shifts, sleep deprivation, social isolation topped with the perennial sword of litigation.

As a way to deal with this stress, some are pushed to self-destructive habits and addictions (alcohol and substance abuse) and some may even resort to the ultimate step of taking one’s own life.

Become a doctor demands lot of self-sacrifice. The extreme stress tests one’s fortitude and perseverance every day.

Overworked and exhausted doctors are bound to mistakes as happened in the case of Dr Bawa-Garba, NHS in UK. She was convicted of manslaughter by gross negligence following the death of a 6-year-old boy with Down syndrome. Her name was erased from the medical register following an appeal from the GMC. Missing the diagnosis of sepsis and thus delaying initiating antibiotic treatment was one among several charges of negligence levelled against her. The charge of manslaughter against their colleague will also adversely affect the morale of other doctors.

Depression therefore is an outcome of the chronic suppression of emotions or need-based desires or their non-fulfilment, particularly for those who have high expectations or high aspirations.

Saturday, March 17, 2018

India soon to have an essential list of diagnostic tests: AMR tests should be on priority






Dr KK Aggarwal


India may soon have an essential list of diagnostic tests along the lines of National List of Essential Medicines (NLEM).

According to the WHO, “essential medicines are those that satisfy the priority health care needs of the population and are intended to be available within the context of functioning health systems at all times in adequate amounts, in the appropriate dosage forms, with assured quality, and at a price the individual and the community can afford.”

Having a list of essential medicines helps to monitor the costs of medicines so that the medicines included are available at affordable costs. Appropriate use of medicines listed in the NLEM promotes rational use of drugs. And, rational use of antimicrobial drugs reduces development of antimicrobial resistance.

Similarly, a national list of essential diagnostic tests would have several advantages such as facilitating therapeutic decisions resulting in improved patient care, affordable tests, reduced out of pocket expenditure and also promote rational use of essential medicines. It would also mean better regulation of diagnostic tests. These tests may be available as either point of care tests or in laboratories.

Ideally speaking, there should be no discrimination of diagnostic tests as essential or non-essential. All tests are essential.

But, if there is to be an essential list of diagnostic tests, then the first priority should be on diagnostic tests for antimicrobial resistance (AMR), a subject of immense public health concern. An essential list of diagnostic tests can be a strategy to check the rising prevalence of AMR. Rapid and correct diagnosis of infections would permit right and more targeted treatment thereby reducing overuse and/or inappropriate use of antimicrobials and in turn, the risk of antimicrobial resistance. This list should be introduced immediately and the rest can wait the bureaucracy. AMR tests should either be made free of cost or their subsidized costs should be uniform across the country.


Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA

Friday, March 16, 2018

Employing Ayush doctors in ICUs is professional misconduct




On Wednesday night, CNN-News18 broadcast a story which showed ICUs in some private hospitals in both Indore and Bengaluru did not have an accredited intensivist or a critical care physician, in charge and instead were being managed by Ayush doctors.

Employing Ayush doctors in ICUs violates the Code of Ethics Regulations as prescribed by the MCI in several ways and is a professional misconduct.

There are no ICUs in Ayush systems of medicine. Hence, their practitioners are inexperienced and/or ill-equipped in managing critically ill patients even with Ayush therapies.

Critical care medicine is a highly specialized field that requires skills to diagnose and manage life-threatening conditions in patients who may be already severely ill. Minimum standards for ICUs to be adopted throughout the country have been suggested by a committee in 2012 under the chairmanship of Prof MK Arora, Dept. of Anesthesiology at AIIMS, New Delhi as below.

Director / Incharge

·         Ideally an ICU must have a full time director or in charge, with full time appointment or at least dedicates 30%- 50% of professional time in ICU (2.1.1).
·         Senior accredited specialist in intensive care medicine with Postgraduate degree (PG) or equivalent   degree   in anesthesiology or internal medicine   or surgery   or critical care medicine.  He  should  have  formal  education/  training  and  experience  in intensive  care medicine  with preferably  5 - 7 years (full time) work experience  in intensive/  critical care medicine. Available upon request on notice in the hospital during "off duty hours (2.1.3).

Consultants

·         Should possess MCI (Medical Council of India) recognized postgraduate degree in (PG) or  equivalent  degree  in  Anesthesia,  Medicine  or  Surgery  or Physicians  qualified  in intensive care medicine (2.2.1.1).
·         Should have minimum 3 years experience after post-graduation of which 3-6 months experience in intensive/ critical care medicine  (One with teaching experience  in critical care medicine is preferred (2.2.1.2)

Resident doctors (Academic or non-academic or fellows)

·         A minimum of two resident doctors must be on duty in an ICU and they must be on duty for 24 hours x 7 days (2.2.3.1).
·         One of the resident doctor must be a postgraduate in anesthesia or medicine or surgery with minimum of 3 months (preferable   6 months) full time working experience in ICU. The other resident doctor can be a trainee (Academic or fellow trainees after 1 years of training in their primary specialty and within the frame of their specialty, work in an ICU under clearly defined supervision) (2.2.3.2).
·         One resident doctor to take care of not more than five patients (2.2.3.3).


Any doctor who employs an Ayush practitioner as an assistant is responsible for his/her actions. This has been clearly stated in Regulation 7.18 of MCI Code of Ethics “In the case of running of a nursing home by a physician and employing assistants to help him / her, the ultimate responsibility rests on the physician.”

While 7.18 does not “restrict the proper training and instruction of bonafide students, midwives, dispensers, surgical attendants, or skilled mechanical and technical assistants and therapy assistants under the personal supervision of physicians”, it does not allow issuing directions to Ayush doctors with regard to patient care in ICUs during rounds or otherwise. This would amount to training of training of Ayush doctors in critical medicine and violates the provisions of Regulation 7.10, which says, “A registered medical practitioner shall not issue certificates of efficiency in modern medicine to unqualified or non-medical person”.

Employing Ayush doctors to take care of patients in ICUs amounts to fraud, cheating and impersonification on the part of hospital owners, medical superintendent of that hospital including other doctors, if they are aware that Ayush doctors have been employed. Moreover, this does not have the consent of the patients.

All doctors who assign them duties including those who interview Ayush doctors to hire them in their hospitals are also liable for professional misconduct.  

As per Regulation 1.6 Highest Quality Assurance in patient care: “Every physician should aid in safeguarding the profession against admission to it of those who are deficient in moral character or education. Physician shall not employ in connection with his professional practice any attendant who is neither registered nor enlisted under the Medical Acts in force and shall not permit such persons to attend, treat or perform operations upon patients wherever professional discretion or skill is required”.

As doctors, patient safety and care is our first and foremost concern.

The Govt., Association and Regulators should take suo moto cognizance of this report and take appropriate action.


Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA