Showing posts with label High Court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label High Court. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 10, 2019

Courts should make guidelines and leave it to the medical boards and not handle the cases themselves?




Dr KK Aggarwal & Advocate Ira Gupta

Now and then women approach the courts for termination for pregnancy on medical grounds. Instead of approaching the courts, the government should come out with clear cut guidelines, based on which the medical board can take a decision in such cases.

Like in MCI ethics regulation 6.7 “ …the question of withdrawing supporting devices to sustain cardio-pulmonary function even after brain death, shall be decided only by a team of doctors and not merely by the treating physician alone…”

The following two cases illustrate this.

Terminations under 20 weeks isn’t our business: High Court

Unwanted pregnancies under 20 weeks can be medically terminated by doctors directly, and the woman need not be referred to medical board nor be asked to approach courts for remedy, the Madras high court has said. The court also said doctors & police officials need to be sensitized to the issues surrounding unwanted pregnancies as they often misconstrue the provisions of Termination of Pregnancy Act.

Coming to the rescue of a woman who wanted to terminate her eight-week-old fetus forced on her by a man known to her, Justice Anand Venkatesh said if a criminal case is pending, samples will be taken for DNA test of both mother & the conceptus (fetus & placenta).

In all cases, where a victim girl suffers an unwanted pregnancy & where the length of pregnancy does not exceed 20 weeks, the victim girl need not be referred to the medical board & the termination of pregnancy can be done as per the provisions of Act. The victim girl should not be unnecessarily made to knock the doors of this court.

Madras High Court allows termination of 26-week pregnancy

The Madras high court has allowed the termination of a woman’s 26-week pregnancy after medical tests revealed that the fetus had health complications and the child would require multiple and extensive surgeries with a remote chance of survival.

The Trichy woman moved the court seeking permission to terminate the pregnancy after the legally permissible gestation time of 20 weeks. Scan reports during the 18th week of her pregnancy revealed that the fetus seemed to have dilated ventricles — a brain condition.

The court, subsequently directed her to appear for a medical examination at the Tuticorin Government Medical College Hospital, where a medical board comprising a paediatrician, neurosurgeon, neurologist, cardiologist & obstetrician assessed her previous medical reports & subjected her to various tests & filed a report before the court.

The medical board was of the unanimous opinion that the woman should be allowed to abort the fetus. The bench cited the medical expert’s opinion & said, “Even if the child in the womb is born, its survival will be medically remote as it has to confront numerous surgeries, which cannot assure its longevity.” In such circumstances, if the pregnancy is not ordered to be terminated, the woman would be subjected to mental trauma & hardship, the court ruled.

Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
President Elect Confederation of Medical Associations in Asia and Oceania   (CMAAO)
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Past National President IMA

Wednesday, June 19, 2019

Supreme Court defers hearing of petition seeking protection for Doctors


Dr KK Aggarwal & Advocate Ira Gupta

The Supreme Court has deferred the hearing in the petition seeking protection for Doctors in the government hospitals.

The Court was of the view that while the larger question of protection for Doctors needs consideration, the matter is not urgent anymore given the fact that the strike by the Doctors in West Bengal, as well as other States, has now been called off.

The Vacation Bench of Justices Deepak Gupta and Surya Kant thus directed that the petition be listed before an appropriate Bench after vacation.

The questions relating to the kind of protection and who shall be responsible for providing the same will be considered by the Court.

The PIL seeks a direction to the Central government to deploy uniformed security personnel at every government hospital to ensure the safety of doctors. Srivastava has also prayed for a direction to the government to formulate guidelines for the safety of doctors and for the same to be implemented in "letter and spirit".

Additionally, the petition also seeks a direction to the State of West Bengal to take stringent action against those who assaulted the junior doctor in NRS Medical College and Hospital, Kolkata.

Doctors in the hospital had gone on strike after a Junior Doctor Paribaha Mukhopadhyay was severely injured after being attacked by a mob of people. The assault took place after the death of a 75- year old patient.

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee had criticised the agitation and urged the doctors to resume work. This sparked protests in other Kolkata hospitals and eventually spread to other parts of the country.

The matter had even reached the Calcutta High Court, which last week urged the State government to take measures to resolve the grievances raised by the striking doctors. The matter in the High Court is scheduled to be heard on June 21.



Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
President Elect Confederation of Medical Associations in Asia and Oceania (CMAAO)
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Past National President IMA

Wednesday, September 7, 2011

Emedinews:Another Bomb Blast in Delhi

A powerful bomb exploded outside Delhi High Court gate number 5 on Wednesday morning. The blast took place at around 10.15 am. It left 11 people dead and more than 100 injured. This is the second such incident at the High Court this year.

Half of all early casualties seek medical care over first hour. To know the total number of casualties, double this number after one hour. This formula is often used by the media to predict the tolls. It is also useful to predict demand for care and resource needs.

The most severely injured arrive after the less injured who self–transport to the closest hospitals, so always expect upside down triage.

It is important that we as doctors know how bomb blast cause injuries in order to tackle the repercussions of bomb blasts. Bomb blast injuries can be categorized into four types:

• Primary blast injuries are a direct result of the impact of the over pressurized blast wave on the body. It involves injuries to the hollow gas–filled organs like the lungs, ear drum or intestines leading to their rupture.
• Secondary blast injuries occur due to flying debris and bomb fragments causing penetration or penetrating injuries to organs such as eyes.
• Tertiary blast injuries occur when individuals are thrown by the blast wind leading to fractures due to the fall.
• Quaternary blast injuries are due to direct effect of burn or crush injuries.
The most important aspect is not to waste energies and resources on patients with non-serious injuries.
Look for eardrum rupture and signs of respiratory imbalance. Their absence indicates a non–serious injury.
• If the ear drums are intact, the patient can be discharged with first–aid treatment.
• If ear drum is ruptured, immediately do an X–ray chest. Keep the patient under observation for eight hours as primary blast injuries may have a delayed presentation.
Hence, otoscopic ear exam can be used as a screening procedure for triage. Decreased oxygen saturation on pulse oximetry signals early blast lung injury, even before symptoms become apparent.