Showing posts with label Kerala High Court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kerala High Court. Show all posts

Sunday, October 28, 2018

Homosexuals in a live-in relationship is not a crime, rules Kerala High Court



Advocate Ira Gupta & Dr KK Aggarwal

In a string of progressive judgments being passed by the Indian Judiciary, the High Court of Kerala in this recent case has allowed lesbian couple to lead a live-in relationship noting that the same is not a crime or contrary to any Indian law.

In the case titled as “Sreeja S. versus The Commissioner of Police”, the seminal and intriguing issue that fell for consideration before the High Court of Kerala was “whether persons of same gender are entitled to lead a ‘live-in relationship’?

The petitioner, a lady, alleged that her ‘lesbian partner’, ‘A’, years is under illegal of her parents, against her free will. Accordingly, the Petitioner in the case prayed production of the corpus of the alleged detenue and to set her at liberty.

The High Court in view of the facts of the case noted that the larger issue in the case was whether detenu can be permitted to go along with the petitioner to lead a ‘live-in relationship’, because both of them belong to the same gender, and could not solemnize a valid marriage between them?

While arriving at its decision in favour of the Petitioner, the High Court made reference to recent string of cases highlighting the freedom of choice of an individual and the validity of adults to have a live-in relationship.

With respect to permitting of ‘live-in relationship’ the High Court made reference to the recent case of Nandakumar and another V. State of Kerala and others, whereby the Supreme Court noted that, even if the parties are not competent to enter into the wedlock, they have the right to live together even outside the wedlock. The Court also observed that ‘live-in relationship’ was now recognized by the Legislature itself which has found its place under the provisions of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005.


Finally, the High Court in the present case observed that the ‘live-in relationship’ between the petitioner and the alleged detenue will in no manner offend any provisions of law or it will become a crime in any manner and the Court directed to set the alleged detenue at liberty to go along with the petitioner, as desired by her.

(Source: Vakilno1)

Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
President Elect Confederation of Medical Associations in Asia and Oceania   (CMAAO)
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA

Saturday, May 19, 2018

Kerala High Court rules that talking on a mobile phone while driving is not illegal




On Wednesday i.e. on 16.05.2018, the Hon'ble Kerala High Court ruled that talking on a mobile phone while driving is not illegal. It ordered that the police cannot register a case against those who talk on the mobile phone while driving, unless the act causes a danger to the public.

The police had registered a case under and Section 118(e) of Kerala Police Act.

Section 118(e) of Kerala Police Act states that any person who knowingly does any act which causes danger to public or failure in public safety shall on conviction be punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend up to three years or with a fine not exceeding Rs 10,000/- or with both.

The Hon'ble Division Bench of the High Court said that the police can’t register case as there are no provisions in the law to book a person for this.

The court said that police action is possible only if the Act of talking over phone causes danger to public. “Also, there is no provision in the police act that bans people from talking over the mobile phone while driving. Hence a person doing the act cannot be assumed as one who causes danger to the public,” the court said. The Hon'ble High Court expounded that if a case should be registered, the law should be amended and should be passed in the Legislative Assembly.

The Hon'ble Division Bench’s ruling was in response to a petition filed by MJ Santhosh, a native of Kakkanad in Ernakulam questioning the police for registering a case against him using the provisions of the Act. (Source: Latestlaws.com)

This judgement is applicable only to the state of Kerala. However, it may set an unhealthy precedent.

It is dangerous to talk on mobile phones, whether hand-held or hands-free while driving as it distracts the driver. Distracted driving has now become a leading cause of road traffic accidents. Using a radio or navigation system, looking at people on the road side or billboards, eating or drinking, texting, reaching for any object etc. while driving are other examples of distracted driving.

As stated in the ‘Road Accidents in India-2016’ report of the Ministry of Road Transport & Highways, talking on mobile phones while driving resulted in 4, 976 road accidents, 2,138 road accident deaths and injuries to 4,746 number of persons during the year 2016 (PIB, September 6, 2017).

Drivers who use a mobile phone are about four times more likely to be involved in a crash compared to those not using a phone, according to a 2011 World Health Organization (WHO) report on the impact of mobile phone use on driving. And this increased risk is similar for both hand-held and hands-free phones.

Evidence shows that use of mobile phones impairs driving by longer reaction times (braking reaction time, reaction to traffic signals), impaired ability to keep in the correct lane, shorter following distances, and an overall decline in awareness of the driving situation.

So, drive safe…

Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA