Showing posts with label policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label policy. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 18, 2020

COVID 19 symptomatic cases testing or asymptomatic cases testing


COVID 19 symptomatic cases testing or asymptomatic cases testing

Dr KK Aggarwal
President CMAAO, HCFI and Past National President IMA

Symptomatic cases testing

1.       To keep community transmission under check about 1000 sample checks will be done per week
2.        Sampling in private labs has been made available.
3.        72 functional labs of the apex medical body conducting tests and another 49 private NABL-accredited labs will soon be operational.
4.        He also appealed to all private laboratories to offer COVID-19 diagnosis free of cost.
5.        ICMR has asked private labs to do it free (testing or collection?)
6.        Private testing will be done only with the referral of a doctor.
7.        People can just call on the helpline numbers given by the Ministry of Health and officials will collect samples of people for testing from their homes
8.        One million testing kits have been ordered along with more test centres to be added by the end of this week

Let us see the numbers

1.       Only symptomatic people are tested
2.       For everyone symptomatic we have 50 asymptomatic cases
3.       For everyone case with breathless ness we have 4 mild cases with only cough and fever
4.       Mean Time to symptoms is 5 days
5.       Mean time to breathlessness is 9 days
6.       If you close the borders and stop importing the new virus, in 4-6 weeks you will catch all possible symptomatic cases inspite of few asymptomatic or mildly symptomatic people cheating.
7.       This policy is only successful if your international borders closure policy is successful.

Other policy is test test and test policy of asymptomatic cases
1.       You are liberal in testing
2.       Advantage is less coronxiety.
3.       Negative cases are not quarantined
4.       Imagine a negative person quarantined and after 14 days actually gets an infection
5.       Test is positive on day one while symptoms appear on day 5.


Saturday, January 25, 2020

25 Jan Indian Govt should pay for the treatment of India trapped in China with Corona Virus


25 Jan Indian Govt should pay for the treatment of India trapped in China with Corona Virus


To Shri Narendra Modi ji
Hon’ble Prime Minister of India

Dear sir


Subject: Preeti Maheshwari the first Indian victim of coronavirus in China needs ₹1 crore for treatment. The Indian Government should pay


The family of Indian national afflicted with the coronavirus pneumonia and battling for life has reached out to India for financial help reports The Mint.

Unable to fund ₹1 crore needed for Preeti Maheshwari’s treatment in China, her brother Manish Thapa, an employee at Amazon, Bengaluru has reached out to the Indian embassy in Beijing for financial help. He has also got in touch with a healthcare crowd funding platform in India to arrange for her hospital expenses.

Maheshwari, a primary art school teacher at the International School of Science and Technology, Shenzhen, is suffering from coronavirus pneumonia, type 1 respiratory failure, multiple organ dysfunction syndrome (MODS) and septic shock. She is undergoing treatment in the intensive care unit at Shekou Hospital in Shenzhen, China, and is on external respiratory support, ventilators, dialysis and blood purification process.

Currently the treatment is costing 10 lakh Chinese Yuan which is Rs. 1 crore in Indian currency.

The family is also considering shifting her to India for further treatment if needed.

Comments: In these situations, Indian Government should take the responsibilities of treatment of such cases and get them treated in the country where they get infected. If the same is not done Indians getting corona virus infection in China will supress their information about fever and cough symptoms, take anti fever and anti cough medicines to dodge the immigration. This will be much more costly to the country than to treat people like Preeti.

An urgent policy decision is needed in this regard. When the country can support all Indians to get citizenship from neighbouring countries during hardship this policy will be a goodwill policy for Indians trapped in china in need of treatment.


Recipient of four National Awards (Padma Shri, Vishwa Hindi Samman, Dr B C Roy National Award and National Science Communication Award)
President Confederation of Medical Associations of Asia and Oceania
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Chairman HCFI Round Table on Health & wellness, Building Consensus
Past National President and Past Honorary Secretary General, Indian Medical Association