Saturday, April 21, 2018

A heartfelt tribute to my friend and colleague



Dr KK Aggarwal
Recipient of Padma Shri

Yesterday, Dr Rajiv Dhir, my friend and colleague of many years, suddenly decided to hide himself from us forever and hereafter to stay on with us, in our memory and soul.

He was always an active member of IMA and DMA and was working with me for the last several years.

A General Practitioner, Writer, Editor and Leader, he always had a smile and a cheerful word for everybody. It remains upon us to keep his memory alive.

This brings to my mind the question of life after death. Life is nothing but a connection between wave and particle. Death occurs when they disconnect with each other. The particle then merges with the five elements and the wave part stays alive merging with the virtual part of the waves.

As per Bhagawad Gita, whatever you think becomes your habit; whatever your habits, will be your thoughts and whatever your thoughts are at the time of death, will decide the next journey for those who believe in it.

The purpose of our life is to think positive, do positive at every step in life.

Live everyday of your life to the fullest…the most predictable thing about life is its unpredictability.


Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA

Friday, April 20, 2018

Think of innovative conference gifts

Flowers, shawls, mementos are generally presented to distinguished faculty and eminent speakers during conferences or other meetings. I personally have a collection of more than 800 of such gifts, which I have kept in my office. However, most people dispose of the gifts after a period of time. Flowers, anyways, last only for few days, depending on the season.
When I was National President Indian Medical Association, I calculated that all the branches of IMA were perhaps spending a huge amount of money on flowers alone to be given at various functions. I decided not to take flowers.

The answer therefore is to look for innovative gifts to give, even as mementos, which the receiver can use. Some of these gifts can be books, emergency kits.

Yesterday, I was invited by Secretary New Delhi Municipal Council (NDMC) Ms Rashmi Singh IAS to attend a function organized by NDMC. The memento given was a 2 kg fire extinguisher.

I thought it was a good memento and truly appreciated this unique gift. Innovative gifts such as this can be given as a Memento. Not only will the person keep it, it may also save somebodys life.

Thursday, April 19, 2018

Every food-borne illness outbreak should be treated to its source



Recently, the CDC investigated a multistate outbreak of E. coli in the US and sourced it to Romain lettuce grown from the Yuma, Arizona growing region, although no particular grower, supplier, distributor, or brand has been identified. Further to this, the CDC issued an advisory for the consumers as well as retailers and restaurants.

For consumers, the CDC has recommended that they should “ask retailers where their romaine lettuce was sourced from and not eat or buy chopped romaine lettuce from Yuma, Arizona. If you have already bought products containing chopped romaine lettuce, such as bagged salads, salad mixes or prepared salads, throw them away and do not eat them”. Similarly, the CDC has asked retailers, restaurants, and other food service operators to not sell or serve any chopped romaine lettuce from the winter growing areas in Yuma, Arizona. If the source of the chopped romaine lettuce cannot be determined, then it should neither be sold nor served.

Food adulteration is not uncommon in India. Stories of food adulteration, are often covered by media. Milk and milk products, food grains, pulses, flour, condiments, sugar, spices and condiments, vegetables, salt are amongst the most common adulterated foods. The last major food recall across the country perhaps was for Maggi Noodles in 2015 due to lead content beyond the permissible levels.

In India, most cases of food contamination are passed off as food poisoning. The patient is treated for his symptoms and the matter ends there.

The Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) has issued guidelines for food recall by food business operators (FBO). Released last year, these guidelines require all FBOs engaged in the manufacturing, or importing, or wholesale supply of packaged food products to have a recall plan. An FBO is a person who carries on any activity related to manufacture, process, packaging, storage, transportation, distribution or import of food or provides food services. However, FBOs in food retail service sector (such as restaurants, caterers, take-away joints, etc.) who are not engaged in the foregoing activities are not required to have a recall plan.

The onus is on the FBOs to have a recall plan and implement it. Is there a system in place to check if these guidelines are implemented, if at all in the first place and then how stringently are they being implemented? To ensure food safety and thereby public health, there should be no exemptions to these guidelines.

Food adulteration is a punishable offence under the Indian Penal Code: Adulteration of food or drink intended for sale (IPC 272) and sale of noxious food or drink (IPC 273).

Every food-borne illness outbreak should be treated to its source like in the US and an advisory or health warning issued for the general public.

When will we reach such a level in India?


Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA

Wednesday, April 18, 2018

AQI to monitor air quality should also include the toxic VOCs


Air pollution has become a matter of great concern now both for the environment as well as human health. But, when we talk of air pollution, it is the particulate matter, both PM2.5 and PM10, which garner the most attention. Most advisories for air pollution also define actions to control ‘particle’ pollution and how to avoid exposure to particulate matter. But, we ignore other important pollutants such as volatile organic compounds or VOCs, which are gases that are released into the air from products or processes. 

VOCs can be present in both indoor and outdoor environments.

Sources of indoor VOCs include household products like cleaners and disinfectants, paints and other solvents, air fresheners, cosmetics and deodorants, acetone in nail polish removers, dry-cleaned clothing, and pesticides. Glues and adhesives, permanent markers, varnishes, photographic solutions, copiers and printers are other sources of indoor VOCs.

Petroleum products and diesel, wood burning, industrial emissions and chemical solvents are sources of outdoor VOCs.

VOCs are the main precursors to the formation of surface or ground level or tropospheric ‘bad’ ozone and particulate matter, which together form smog. Smog is known to have adverse effects on human health and the environment. Chemical reactions between nitrogen oxides (NOx) and VOCs in sunlight form the ground level ozone, which is harmful, unlike the ozone layer high up in the atmosphere, which acts as a shield and protects from harmful UV rays. The thinning of this stratospheric ‘good’ ozone layer is seen as a hole, colloquially called ‘ozone hole’. Traffic emissions constitute more than half of the ozone precursors.

Acute exposure to VOCs causes irritation of the eyes, nose and throat, headaches, loss of coordination and nausea. Long-term exposure damages the liver, kidneys and the brain.

Some VOCs such as benzene are suspected or known to cause cancer in humans. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) has classified benzene as Group 1 carcinogen i.e. confirmed as carcinogenic to humans. World Health Organization (WHO) guidelines on benzene say that “No specific guideline value has been developed for air. Benzene is carcinogenic to humans, and no safe level of exposure can be recommended”.

The AQI takes into consideration eight pollutants (PM10, PM2.5, NO2, SO2, CO, O3, NH3 and Pb) and their levels are constantly monitored. However, the AQI does not monitor the quantity of VOCs.

But, VOCs are also major toxic air pollutants, which are also hazardous to human health, more so, because they are also present in high concentrations in the indoor environment causing prolonged exposure. VOCs have long-term adverse effects on health unlike particle pollutants, which have immediate impact such as acute asthma exacerbation or an acute cardiac event. Benzene, a VOC, is a known human carcinogen.  

There is therefore a need to create public awareness about VOCs, their sources and harmful effect on health as a first step towards controlling and preventing exposure to this health hazard. Also, regulations should be in place to monitor the environmental levels of these toxic air pollutants.

Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA

Tuesday, April 17, 2018

Guidelines to protect doctors from unjust prosecution should be promptly implemented


Two doctors of Fortis hospital in Gurugram were arrested last week following findings of the district medical board, which said that they had failed to timely administer proper treatment to the patient who died of cardiac arrest last year. The two concerned doctors were arrested under Section 304 IPC (causing death by negligence) and released on bail. The patient, a 51-year-old woman was admitted to the hospital in an emergency on May 12, 2017 following complaint of chest pain around 1.35am. ECG was done at 1.45am. The medical board constituted to examine the case found that the patient was not given anti-platelet treatment as per protocol. According to the medical board, the doctors should have ideally given her an anti-platelet medicine for blood thinning immediately. The report of cardiac enzyme done around 2.23am also indicated the urgent need for medicines to prevent a heart attack. Patient suffered a cardiac arrest in the ICU around 4.30 am. She became very critical and had to be put on life support about which the husband was informed. An angiography done at 7 am showed that the left anterior descending artery was 100% blocked. The patient was declared dead at 9.48 am.

According to the report, emergency medical officer “admitted” before the board that he did not administer anti-platelets. While, the Chief cardiologist said that he had asked the resident cardiologist, to provide “all necessary treatment” to the patient around 2.15am. The Board found in its report that “proper treatment” was not given following examination of hospital records and termed this as “gross negligence” that proved fatal for the patient (ET Healthworld, April 14, 2018).


Without going into the merits of the case, some factors must be considered in general.

Which doctor was on duty at the time of the incident? Was it a junior resident doctor or a senior doctor? Ideally, an intensivist should be on duty or on call in the casualty.

Women generally do not present with the classic pattern of pain on the left side of the chest in the event of a heart attack. They may have atypical symptoms such as pain in the jaw, neck or back, or they may present with symptoms like shortness of breath, cough, or nausea. This is one of the reasons for a delayed diagnosis.

The landmark judgement of the Supreme Court of India on medical negligence in the matter of Jacob Mathew vs State of Punjab & Anr in 2005 has held that “A mere deviation from normal professional practice is not necessarily evidence of negligence. Let it also be noted that a mere accident is not evidence of negligence. So also an error of judgment on the part of a professional is not negligence per se. Higher the acuteness in emergency and higher the complication, more are the chances of error of judgment… No sensible professional would intentionally commit an act or omission which would result in loss or injury to the patient as the professional reputation of the person is at stake. A single failure may cost him dear in his career.” If you missed a diagnosis, this is not criminal negligence, at the most, it can be a civil negligence. But, whenever there is any doubt, the specialist should be called at once, especially in an emergency.

In the same judgement, Jacob Mathew vs State of Punjab & Anr, the Hon’ble Supreme Court had also directed that guidelines be formulated by the Govt. after conferring with the MCI for such an eventuality.

“The investigating officer and the private complainant cannot always be supposed to have knowledge of medical science so as to determine whether the act of the accused medical professional amounts to rash or negligent act within the domain of criminal law under Section 304-A of IPC. The criminal process once initiated subjects the medical professional to serious embarrassment and sometimes harassment. He has to seek bail to escape arrest, which may or may not be granted to him. At the end he may be exonerated by acquittal or discharge but the loss which he has suffered in his reputation cannot be compensated by any standards.”

A Study Group had prepared and submitted draft “Guidelines for protecting doctors from frivolous or unjust prosecution against medical negligence” last year to the MCI for further action. These guidelines have been approved by the MCI. It is now for the Govt. to notify these guidelines and implement them.

1.    “The Prosecuting Agency on receipt of any complaint of which criminal rashness or negligence is an ingredient against a registered medical practitioner under the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 prior to making arrest refer the complaint to the Chief Medical Officer of a District who shall place it before the District Medical Board for its recommendations as regards the merit of the allegations of criminal rashness or negligence, contained in the complaint.
2.    The District Medical Board on receipt of such reference examine the allegation contained therein in a time-bound manner, preferably within two-weeks, and thereafter forward its recommendation to the Prosecuting Agency through the Chief Medical Officer of the District.
3.    The District Medical Board that has examined the complaint must ensure a Doctor qualified in that branch of medical science is part of the Board.
4.    The Prosecuting Agency, in case, it is dissatisfied with the recommendation of the District Medical Board may stating the reasons for such dissatisfaction refer the matter to the Divisional Medical Board for its recommendation within a period of three-weeks from the date of receipt of recommendation of the District Medical Board.
5.    The Divisional Medical Board, on receipt of any such reference from the Prosecuting Agency would examine the matter within a period of three-weeks from the date of receipt of such reference. The Divisional Medical Board shall provide reason for endorsing or rejecting the recommendation of the District Medical Board. The decision of the Divisional Medical Board shall expeditiously be conveyed to the prosecuting agency, and in any case not later than four-weeks from the date of receipt of reference made by the prosecuting agency.
6.    The Prosecuting Agency, in case, it is it is dissatisfied with the recommendation of the Divisional Medical Board may stating the reasons for such dissatisfaction refer the matter to the State Medical Board for its recommendation within a period of four-weeks from the date of receipt of recommendation of the Divisional Medical Board.
7.    The State Medical Board, on receipt of any such reference from the Prosecuting Agency would examine the matter within a period of four-weeks from the date of receipt of such reference. The State Medical Board shall provide reason for endorsing or rejecting the recommendation of the Divisional Medical Board. The decision of the State Medical Board shall be expeditiously conveyed to the prosecuting agency, and in any case not later than five-weeks from the date of receipt of reference made by the prosecuting agency.
8.    The Prosecuting Agency on the receipt of Recommendation of the District/Divisional/State Medical Board further proceed in the matter in accordance with law. However, in case arrest of a registered medical practitioner in the employment of State/Central Government is being made, the Controlling Officer of such Medical Practitioner would be informed by the Prosecuting Agency. Likewise, in case, the registered medical practitioner is engaged in private practice, the concerned State Medical Council, or in case there is no State Medical Council in that State/Union Territory, the Medical Council of India be informed.”

More and more doctors are facing criminal prosecution. This instance adds to this growing list. We should fight for the prompt implementation of these guidelines.





Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India

Immediate Past National President IMA


Monday, April 16, 2018

Unqualified and untrained quacks are posing a great risk to the entire society



A number of unqualified, untrained quacks are posing a great risk to the entire society and playing with the lives of people without having the requisite training and education in the science from approved institutions.

Dr KK Aggarwal and Ira Gupta

In the matter titled as Kerala Ayurveda Paramparya Vaidya Forum Versus State of Kerala and Others, Civil Appeal 897/2009 the Hon’ble Supreme Court comprising of bench of Hon’ble Mr. Justice R. K. Aggarwal and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Mohan M. Shantanagoudar vide judgment dated 13.04.2018 has dealt with the issue whether the persons who do not fulfill the prescribed qualification and are not duly registered under the relevant Statute, be permitted to practice as ‘Paramparya Vaidyas’?

The facts of the case are:
(a) In the State of Kerala, a number of persons are practicing in Sidha/Unani/Ayurveda system of medicine called as “Paramparya Vaidyas’ and passing their knowledge and experience to their descendants by way of training and practice. Normally, almost all the descendants in the family get training in the same field and adopt this as a profession and means of livelihood.
(b) Pursuant to the enactment of the Travancore-Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1953 (in short ‘the Act’), the ‘Paramparya Vaidyas’ were debarred from practicing modern/homoeopathic/ayurvedic/siddha/unani-tibbi medicines unless registered under the Act. Subsequently, three Central Acts, viz., The Indian Medical Council Act, 1956, The Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970 and the Homoeopathy Central Council Act, 1973 with regard to modern medicine, indigenous medicine and homoeopathic medicine respectively came into force.
(c)   Being aggrieved by the enactment of the Act, Akhila Kerala Parambarya Vaidya Federation as well as the persons practicing as ‘Paramparya Vaidyas’ filed a number of petitions before the High Court. Learned single Judge of the High Court, taking note of an affidavit filed by the State Government stating that the question of granting registration to practice medicines to the ‘Paramparya Vaidyas’ can be considered at the time of enactment of Kerala Medical Practitioners Bill, by order dated 17.06.1997 in O.P. No. 118 of 1991 and other set of petitions, disposed of the original petitions while directing the State Government to have a serious consideration of the circumstances expeditiously.
(d) Several petitions were filed before the High Court by the ‘Paramparya Vaidyas’ claiming that the methods had been in vogue for a considerable long period of time. The Division Bench of the High Court, vide order dated 08.01.2003 dismissed the petitions filed by the appellants herein. Aggrieved by the order dated 08.01.2003, the appellants have preferred these appeals by way of special leave.

After hearing the arguments of all the parties, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that:
            19) In our country, the numbers of qualified medical practitioners have been much less than the required number of such persons. The scarcity of qualified medical practitioner was previously quite large since there were very few institutions imparting teaching and training to Doctors, Vaidyas, Hakims etc. The position has now changed and there are quite a good number of medical colleges imparting education in various streams of medicine. No doubt, now there are a good numbers of such institutions training qualified medical practitioners at number of places. The persons having no recognized and approved qualifications, having little knowledge about the indigenous medicines, are becoming medical practitioners and playing with the lives of thousands and millions of people. Some time such quacks commit blunders and precious lives are lost.

20) The government had been vigilant all along to stop such quackery. A number of unqualified, untrained quacks are posing a great risk to the entire society and playing with the lives of people without having the requisite training and education in the science from approved institutions. The Travancore-Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1953 as well as the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970 were also enacted on the similar lines. Every practitioner shall be deemed to be a practitioner registered under the Act if at the commencement of this Act, his name stands entered in the appropriate register maintained under the said Act and every certificate of registration issued to every such practitioner shall be deemed to be a certificate of registration issued under this Act. But in the present case, the appellants herein have failed to show that they possessed requisite recognized qualification for registration entitling them to practice Indian system of medicines or their names have been entered in the appropriate registers after the commencement of this Act.”



Sunday, April 15, 2018

Speak to type




A friend recently introduced me to two new features of Google Chrome: ‘Voice typing’ and ‘Search by Voice’.

To start voice typing, open a new document in Google Docs in a Chrome Browser. Select ‘Tools’ from the Menu Bar. In the Drop down menu, click on the Microphone Icon, a microphone box appears.  Click on the microphone icon to start voice typing; once activated, it becomes red. Start speaking.

You will find that as you speak, the words are automatically typed in the document. Speak clearly and loudly. You can also type in Hindi or any other language; click on the drop down menu to select the language. You can edit the document later.

You can also do a Voice search in Google. Click on the mike on the Google search bar and speak up. Instead of typing your keywords in the search bar, speak them aloud. Voice search is faster and also easier.

Not all of us are very proficient in typing on the keyboard as the younger generation. Use these features to save time. Just sit back and start ‘typing’ as you speak, even as you enjoy the freedom of movement instead of sitting at a desk hunched over a keyboard. You can use it to make patient summary or discharge ticket or other relevant notes.



Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA