#DrKKAnswers: Many doctors who graduated before 1990 may not be aware about the guidelines as regards hunger strikers. The first declaration of World Medical Assembly was adopted in 1991, revised in 1992 and then again revised in 2006. It is called the ‘WMA Declaration of Malta on Hunger Strikers’. It describes the duties of a doctor and guidelines for the management of hunger strikers. As per the WMA Declaration, all physicians are bound by Medical Ethics even when not providing therapy. They must try to prevent coercion or maltreatment of detainees and must protest if it occurs. It is the duty of the physicians to take the hunger striker in confidence in isolation and find out his or her intention before and during the fast.
Showing posts with label Hunger Strike. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hunger Strike. Show all posts
Friday, August 19, 2011
Thursday, August 18, 2011
HCFI Update: Formula of three for hunger strike and Satyagraha
Rough formula of 3 is that one cannot live for three minutes without air, three days without water and three weeks without food said Padmashri and Dr B C Roy National Awardee Dr KK Aggarwal President Heart Care Foundation of India and President MTNL Perfect Health Mela.
But this formula is for healthy muscular and fatty people. People who are in their extremes of ages or are suffering from a chronic ailment, pregnant ladies, diabetics should not fast without a doctor’s clearance.
Dr Aggarwal said that a large number of people are joining Anna Hazare for fast. All are not fit and may loose health. Medically observed spiritual fats can be helpful for the body but prolonged unsupervised fast can be life risky.
Here are some facts:
1. Fasting is willingly abstaining from some or all food, drink, or both, for a period of time.
2. An absolute fast is abstinence from all food and liquid for a defined period.
3. Partially restrictive fast is limited to particular foods or substances.
4. The fast may be intermittent in nature
5. Fasting medically means the metabolic status of a person who has not eaten overnight, and to the metabolic state achieved after complete digestion and absorption of a meal. A person is assumed to be fasting after 8–12 hours.
6. Metabolic changes after fasting begin after absorption of a meal (typically 3–5 hours after a meal). Medically it is called "post-absorptive state" as against "post-prandial" state of ongoing digestion.
7. A diagnostic fast refers to prolonged fasting (from 8–72 hours depending on age)
8. The longest known fast for a human is 132 days (without food).
9. Glucose is the body's primary fuel source and is essential for the brain's functioning. When denied glucose for more than 4–8 hours, the body turns to the liver for glycogen, a storage form of glucose, to be used for fuel. A process called glycogenolysis converts glycogen into a usable form of fuel. At this point, the body also uses small amounts of protein to supplement this fuel. This fuel will last for up to 12 hours before the body needs to turn to glycogen stored in muscles, lasting for a few more days.
10. If glucose is still denied at this point, muscle wasting is prevented by temporarily switching to fat as the fuel source, meaning fat is converted into ketone through catabolism. Ketones, while not sugars, can be used by the brain as a fuel source as long as glucose is denied. The body continues to use fat for as long as there is fat to consume.
11. If the fast is not broken, starvation begins to occur, as the body begins to use protein for fuel.
12. Health complications associated with fast-induced starvation include electrolyte imbalances, thinning hair, cardiac arrhythmias and renal failure. Death can occur if fasting is pursued to the point of complete starvation.
13. Hypovolemia refers to any condition in which the extracellular fluid volume is reduced. It can be produced by dehydration.
Wednesday, June 15, 2011
Can a person die after his prolonged fast is broken?
Nine days fast by Ramdev, death of another swami in Uttarakhand after 115 days fast and now a threat by Anna Hazare to go into fast again has opened a new chapter for one to revise the knowledge as to how to deal with such a person especially one is breaking the fast.
The 35 years old swami who died was protesting the Uttarakhand government's refusal to ban mining along a stretch of Ganga near Rishikesh. He had been on a fast since February 19 2011. On April 27, officials shifted him to Haridwar district hospital as his condition deteriorated but he still refused to touch food. When he slipped into coma on May 2, he was rushed to HIMS and put on life support system. The president of Haridwar Citizen Council, alleged the seer suffered a heart attack at Haridwar district hospital after being injected poison by hospital staff. Did he die of refeeding syndrome or the starvation effects is the question in the mind of the medical fraternity?
The basic aim of breaking any fast is to prevent occurrence of re-feeding syndrome, a metabolic complication that occurs when nutritional support is given to severely malnourished patients or to someone recovering from prolonged fast or hunger strike.
Any individual who has had negligible nutrient intake for 5 consecutive days is at risk. It occurs within four days of starting to feed. Patients who weigh less than 70 percent of ideal body weight or lose weight rapidly are at greatest risk for the syndrome.
During prolonged fasting the body conserve muscle and protein breakdown by switching to ketone bodies derived from fatty acids as the main energy source. The liver decreases its rate of gluconeogenesis thus conserving muscle and protein. Many intracellular minerals become severely depleted during this period, although serum levels may remain normal. Insulin secretion is suppressed and glucagon secretion is increased.
During re-feeding the metabolism shifts from a catabolic to an anabolic state. Insulin is released on carbohydrate intake resulting in increased glycogen, fat and protein synthesis. Insulin release triggers cellular uptake of potassium, phosphate, and magnesium which are already depleted and the stores rapidly become used up. When the serum concentrations of these electrolytes are reduced, serious complications, such as irregular heart beat can occur. Patients can also develop fluid and electrolyte imbalance, low phosphate levels, neurologic, lung, heart, neuromuscular, and blood related complications.
Irregular heart rhythm is the most common cause of death with other significant risks including confusion, coma and convulsions and cardiac failure. The diagnostic feature is presence of low phosphate, potassium, magnesium, vitamin B1 levels and fluid overload with edema feet. Low phosphate levels is the essential criteria for diagnosis.
If the refeeding syndrome occurs, doctors should immediately slow nutritional replenishment and correct low levels of phosphates, potassium and magnesium while monitoring the cardiovascular system.
In patients at risk of re-feeding syndrome, nutritional support is initially delivered at a maximum of 10 kcal/kg/day and raised gradually to full needs within a week. In extreme cases this energy intake is limited to 5 kcal/kg/day.
Before and during the first 10 days of feeding, it is important to give 200-300 mg oral thiamine a day, 1-2 vitamin B complex tablets three times a day or intravenous vitamin B, and a balanced multivitamin and mineral supplement each day.
One should monitor and supplement oral, enteral, or intravenous potassium, phosphate and magnesium in such patients.
On average, patients should receive 2-4 mmol/kg/day potassium, 0.3-0.6 mmol/kg/day phosphate, and 0.2 mmol/kg/day intravenous or 0.4 mmol/kg/day oral magnesium.
Moderately to severely ill patients with marked edema or a serum phosphorous < 2 mg/dL should be hospitalized to intravenously correct electrolyte deficiencies.
About the author
Padmashri & Dr. B.C. Roy National Awardee, Dr. KK Aggarwal is a Senior Consultant, Physician, Cardiologist at Delhi based Moolchand Medcity; President Heart Care Foundation of India; Chairman Ethical Committee Delhi Medical Council and has served as the Research and Academic Wing Heads of National Indian Medical Association.
Labels:
Anna Hazare,
Dr B C Roy National Awardee,
Dr K K Aggarwal,
Dr KK,
fast,
HCFI,
Heart Care Foundation of India,
Hunger Strike,
India,
Padmashri,
Ramdev,
Refeeding Syndrome,
Starvation
Saturday, June 11, 2011
Baba Ramdev Health Bulletin Comments
1. Initially Baba Ram Dev Ji’s BP on 7.6.2011 in haridwar was 110/80 pulse 68/ min wt 60 kg ,urinary ketone 4+, S.bilirubin 1.3 Hb 15.
2. He started his fast on 4.6.2011 in Delhi. According to him his wt was 64 kg before fasting.
3. On 10.6.11 when he was shifted to Jolly grant Dehradun his wt was 58.5 kg. S. bilirubin 2 (on 7.6.2011 S. bilirubin was 1.3) his ketone remain between +2 to +4.
4. Urine albumin was negative on 7.6.2011 but on 10.06.2011 albumin was in traces.
5. Hb was raised to 16 on 10.6.2011 (from 15 gm on 7.6.2011).
6. KFT was normal.
7. Due to starting derangement of LFT, Haemoconcentration due to dehydration falling pulse below 60 (56 to 58 per min) and BP 104/64 he was advised for admission for complete evaluation and treatment.
8. You have rightly commented Swami Ramdev ji was vocal in all these days, and he was among his thousand of followers in a Tent in this summer weather, where Hawan was being performed. He was involved in all the activities .
9. When he reached jolly grant his pulse was 56 per min BP 110/74. One more comment from you about The World Medical Association and Declaration of Malta on Hunger Strikers, in its Article 21, unambiguously state that force feeding is a form of inhuman and degrading treatment. In that case what a doctor should do.He can only advice to take feed as soon as ketone start coming in urine.
10. As coomunicated by Dr Sundeep Nigam
My comments
1. Baba Ramdev is thin built, lean muscle mass, striking in summer eat in an environment of havan ( agni) with an agitating mind
2. He is going into dehydration
3. Bilirubin is rising, is a bad sign
4. He may be in kidney dysfunction for example if his creatinine is 1 his kidney function will be around 70%
5. Giving saline is ethical in this situation
6. Low pulse rate is also a bad sign as in dehydration the pulse should increase and not decrease
[ dr K K Aggarwal, isd padmashri and Dr B C Roy National Awardee and editor emedinews)
GUIDELINES FOR THE MANAGEMENT OF HUNGER STRIKERS
WMA Declaration of Malta on Hunger Strikers
- Physicians must assess individuals' mental capacity. This involves verifying that an individual intending to fast does not have a mental impairment that would seriously undermine the person's ability to make health care decisions. Individuals with seriously impaired mental capacity cannot be considered to be hunger strikers. They need to be given treatment for their mental health problems rather than allowed to fast in a manner that risks their health.
- As early as possible, physicians should acquire a detailed and accurate medical history of the person who is intending to fast. The medical implications of any existing conditions should be explained to the individual. Physicians should verify that hunger strikers understand the potential health consequences of fasting and forewarn them in plain language of the disadvantages. Physicians should also explain how damage to health can be minimised or delayed by, for example, increasing fluid intake. Since the person's decisions regarding a hunger strike can be momentous, ensuring full patient understanding of the medical consequences of fasting is critical. Consistent with best practices for informed consent in health care, the physician should ensure that the patient understands the information conveyed by asking the patient to repeat back what they understand.
- A thorough examination of the hunger striker should be made at the start of the fast. Management of future symptoms, including those unconnected to the fast, should be discussed with hunger strikers. Also, the person's values and wishes regarding medical treatment in the event of a prolonged fast should be noted.
- Sometimes hunger strikers accept an intravenous saline solution transfusion or other forms of medical treatment. A refusal to accept certain interventions must not prejudice any other aspect of the medical care, such as treatment of infections or of pain.
- Physicians should talk to hunger strikers in privacy and out of earshot of all other people, including other detainees. Clear communication is essential and, where necessary, interpreters unconnected to the detaining authorities should be available and they too must respect confidentiality.
- Physicians need to satisfy themselves that food or treatment refusal is the individual's voluntary choice. Hunger strikers should be protected from coercion. Physicians can often help to achieve this and should be aware that coercion may come from the peer group, the authorities or others, such as family members. Physicians or other health care personnel may not apply undue pressure of any sort on the hunger striker to suspend the strike. Treatment or care of the hunger striker must not be conditional upon suspension of the hunger strike.
- If a physician is unable for reasons of conscience to abide by a hunger striker's refusal of treatment or artificial feeding, the physician should make this clear at the outset and refer the hunger striker to another physician who is willing to abide by the hunger striker's refusal.
- Continuing communication between physician and hunger strikers is critical. Physicians should ascertain on a daily basis whether individuals wish to continue a hunger strike and what they want to be done when they are no longer able to communicate meaningfully. These findings must be appropriately recorded.
- When a physician takes over the case, the hunger striker may have already lost mental capacity so that there is no opportunity to discuss the individual's wishes regarding medical intervention to preserve life. Consideration needs to be given to any advance instructions made by the hunger striker. Advance refusals of treatment demand respect if they reflect the voluntary wish of the individual when competent. In custodial settings, the possibility of advance instructions having been made under pressure needs to be considered. Where physicians have serious doubts about the individual's intention, any instructions must be treated with great caution. If well informed and voluntarily made, however, advance instructions can only generally be overridden if they become invalid because the situation in which the decision was made has changed radically since the individual lost competence.
- If no discussion with the individual is possible and no advance instructions exist, physicians have to act in what they judge to be the person's best interests. This means considering the hunger strikers' previously expressed wishes, their personal and cultural values as well as their physical health. In the absence of any evidence of hunger strikers' former wishes, physicians should decide whether or not to provide feeding, without interference from third parties.
- Physicians may consider it justifiable to go against advance instructions refusing treatment because, for example, the refusal is thought to have been made under duress. If, after resuscitation and having regained their mental faculties, hunger strikers continue to reiterate their intention to fast, that decision should be respected. It is ethical to allow a determined hunger striker to die in dignity rather than submit that person to repeated interventions against his or her will.
- Artificial feeding can be ethically appropriate if competent hunger strikers agree to it. It can also be acceptable if incompetent individuals have left no unpressured advance instructions refusing it.
- Forcible feeding is never ethically acceptable. Even if intended to benefit, feeding accompanied by threats, coercion, force or use of physical restraints is a form of inhuman and degrading treatment. Equally unacceptable is the forced feeding of some detainees in order to intimidate or coerce other hunger strikers to stop fasting.
(Adopted by the 43rd World Medical Assembly, St Julians, Malta, November 1991
and revised at the 44th WMA Marbella, Spain, September 1992and revised by the 57th WMA General Assembly, Pilanesberg, South Africa, October 2006)
and revised at the 44th WMA Marbella, Spain, September 1992and revised by the 57th WMA General Assembly, Pilanesberg, South Africa, October 2006)
Preamble
- Hunger strikes occur in various contexts but they mainly give rise to dilemmas in settings where people are detained (prisons, jails and immigration detention centres). They are often a form of protest by people who lack other ways of making their demands known. In refusing nutrition for a significant period, they usually hope to obtain certain goals by inflicting negative publicity on the authorities. Short-term or feigned food refusals rarely raise ethical problems. Genuine and prolonged fasting risks death or permanent damage for hunger strikers and can create a conflict of values for physicians. Hunger strikers usually do not wish to die but some may be prepared to do so to achieve their aims. Physicians need to ascertain the individual's true intention, especially in collective strikes or situations where peer pressure may be a factor. An ethical dilemma arises when hunger strikers who have apparently issued clear instructions not to be resuscitated reach a stage of cognitive impairment. The principle of beneficence urges physicians to resuscitate them but respect for individual autonomy restrains physicians from intervening when a valid and informed refusal has been made. An added difficulty arises in custodial settings because it is not always clear whether the hunger striker's advance instructions were made voluntarily and with appropriate information about the consequences. These guidelines and the background paper address such difficult situations.
PRINCIPLES
- Duty to act ethically. All physicians are bound by medical ethics in their professional contact with vulnerable people, even when not providing therapy. Whatever their role, physicians must try to prevent coercion or maltreatment of detainees and must protest if it occurs.
- Respect for autonomy. Physicians should respect individuals' autonomy. This can involve difficult assessments as hunger strikers' true wishes may not be as clear as they appear. Any decisions lack moral force if made involuntarily by use of threats, peer pressure or coercion. Hunger strikers should not be forcibly given treatment they refuse. Forced feeding contrary to an informed and voluntary refusal is unjustifiable. Artificial feeding with the hunger striker's explicit or implied consent is ethically acceptable.
- 'Benefit' and 'harm'. Physicians must exercise their skills and knowledge to benefit those they treat. This is the concept of 'beneficence', which is complemented by that of 'non-maleficence' or primum non nocere. These two concepts need to be in balance. 'Benefit' includes respecting individuals' wishes as well as promoting their welfare. Avoiding 'harm' means not only minimising damage to health but also not forcing treatment upon competent people nor coercing them to stop fasting. Beneficence does not necessarily involve prolonging life at all costs, irrespective of other values.
- Balancing dual loyalties. Physicians attending hunger strikers can experience a conflict between their loyalty to the employing authority (such as prison management) and their loyalty to patients. Physicians with dual loyalties are bound by the same ethical principles as other physicians, that is to say that their primary obligation is to the individual patient.
- Clinical independence. Physicians must remain objective in their assessments and not allow third parties to influence their medical judgement. They must not allow themselves to be pressured to breach ethical principles, such as intervening medically for non-clinical reasons.
- Confidentiality. The duty of confidentiality is important in building trust but it is not absolute. It can be overridden if non-disclosure seriously harms others. As with other patients, hunger strikers' confidentiality should be respected unless they agree to disclosure or unless information sharing is necessary to prevent serious harm. If individuals agree, their relatives and legal advisers should be kept informed of the situation.
- Gaining trust. Fostering trust between physicians and hunger strikers is often the key to achieving a resolution that both respects the rights of the hunger strikers and minimises harm to them. Gaining trust can create opportunities to resolve difficult situations. Trust is dependent upon physicians providing accurate advice and being frank with hunger strikers about the limitations of what they can and cannot do, including where they cannot guarantee confidentiality.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)