Showing posts with label Indian Medical Association. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Indian Medical Association. Show all posts

Sunday, July 28, 2019

Join the Delhi Andolan on Monday, 29th July




The National Medical Commission Bill 2019 has been approved by the Union cabinet and has been tabled in the Parliament. The Bill provides for setting up of a National Medical Commission (NMC) in place of Medical Council of India (MCI) and repeal of the Indian Medical Council Act 1956.

The Indian Medical Association (IMA) has called for a Delhi Andolan on Monday, 29th July, 2019 to protest against the Bill. It is planned to march to Ministry of Health and Family Welfare at Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi in the forenoon (morning).

On Monday, all doctors wearing their white apron and stethoscope will march to Nirman Bhawan and form a human chain. It will be a silent demonstration without any slogans.

IMA HQs will function as a Control Room for the entire operation. A coordination meeting will be held in IMA HQs at 8 PM on Sunday, 28th July, 2019. All the State Presidents & Secretaries are expected to join the meeting.

Arrangements for the stay of doctors, which includes accommodation, hospitality and transport have also been made by HQs.

This agitation is the culmination of our struggle against NMC Bill for the last 3 years. All State Branches are expected to mobilize at least 1% of their membership to the agitation.

The 1% of the collective consciousness of people decides what 99% will do. This is based on the famous 100th monkey phenomenon. One percent is the critical mass and once this mass is reached, the information well spread like a wild fire and the intent becomes a universal reality.

So, it is time that we join hands to show our solidarity to the cause of the medical profession.

I appeal to you to join the Aandolan and strengthen it further to make it a memorable success.


Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
President Elect Confederation of Medical Associations in Asia and Oceania   (CMAAO)
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Past National President IMA

Wednesday, June 26, 2019

Doctor’s Dilemma





The strike by medical professionals is yet another reminder of the need for a one-time solution in the form of a central act against violence with stringent punishment

By Dr KK Aggarwal

It started as a small protest by doctors at a Kolkata hospital, two of whom were assaulted by a dead patient’s relative. But it did not take long for it to spread into a nationwide movement with government doctors in various states expressing solidarity and resorting to agitations. On June 17, the Indian Medical Association (IMA) staged a 24-hour-long protest across the country, demanding a comprehensive central law to deal with attacks on doctors and healthcare professionals in hospitals. The strike impacted medical services and all non-essential healthcare facilities, including OPDs, were closed from early morning on that day. The IMA also staged a dharna at its headquarters in Delhi.

Mercifully, normalcy was restored later the same day after West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee accepted the demands of the protesting doctors. As the strike was called off, the Supreme Court on June 18 did not pass any order on a PIL seeking measures for the safety and security of doctors in hospitals across India and posted it for July.

The IMA has been urging the centre to frame a central law to check violence against medical professionals in hospitals for a long time. This writer was president of the IMA when it submitted to the centre a draft law in this regard. On June 15, the Union health minister, Dr Harsh Vardhan, attached a copy of the draft in his letter to all chief ministers asking them to frame laws for the protection of medical professionals.

This is not the first time that doctors have been assaulted. A 2015 IMA survey found that over 70 percent of them had faced mental torture and/or physical violence in their careers. It polled 1,781 doctors of whom only 37.7 percent said that they were happy with their profession; 82 percent were stressed out; 34.5 percent had high blood pressure; 18.6 percent had diabetes; 61.6 percent had fear of violence during patient visits; 56.5 percent had thought of hiring security at the place of their practice; 31.6 percent never wanted their children to become doctors; for 45.4 percent, the main source of stress was the fear of violence and 75.6 percent faced anxiety attacks.

There are several legal provisions that deal with the violence against doctors and healthcare professionals:

·         Criminal Law: Any assault or attack on doctors, nurses and other staff, as well as clinical establishments, etc, are punishable under the provisions of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), 1860. The provisions can be further placed under:
1.     Criminal conspiracy—Sections 120A and 120B of IPC
2.     Offences disturbing public tranquility—unlawful assembly (Sections 141, 143 and 144 of IPC), rioting (Sections 146, 147 and 148 of IPC), affray (Sections 159 and 160 IPC).
3.     Offences affecting public health, safety, convenience, decency and morals—public nuisance (Sections 268, 269 and 294 of IPC).
4.     Offences affecting human body—hurt (Sections 319, 323 and 324 of IPC); grievous hurt (Sections 320, 325, 326 and 326A of IPC); act endangering life or personal safety of others (Sections 336 337 and 338 of IPC); wrongful restraint (Sections 339 and 341 of IPC); criminal force and assault (Sections 350, 351, 352 and 355 of IPC).
5.     Offences against property—theft (Sections 378 and 379 of IPC); mischief (Sections 425 and 426 of IPC); criminal trespass (Sections 441 and 447 of IPC).
6.     Offence of defamation (Sections 499 and 500 of IPC).
7.     Offences of criminal intimidation, insult and annoyance (Sections 503, 504 and 506 of IPC).
8.     Offences outraging and insulting the modesty of women (Sections 354, 354A, 354B, 354C and 509 of IPC).

In case of the above mentioned offences, the doctors and their staff can lodge a police complaint under Section 154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and get an FIR registered against the said offender.
·         Civil Law: A civil suit can also be filed by victims on the ground of offences committed as mentioned above. It could be a suit for permanent injunction, for damages or for defamation.
·         Apart from these legal remedies, around 15 states and Union Territories have their respective legislation related to violence against doctors. For example, there is legislation like the Delhi Medicare Service Personnel and Medicare Service Institutions Act, 2008; the Bihar Medical Service Institution and Person Protection Act, 2011, and so on. In all these laws, the accused, once convicted, can be punished with imprisonment which may extend up to three years or fine up to Rs 10,000, or both. The convicted person/s will also have to pay compensation which is twice the price of the damaged property. However, legislation is not effective and doctors and police authorities are hardly aware about the legal provisions.
·         Government doctors have additional protection against violence under IPC Section 186—obstructing a public servant in discharge of public functions which says: “Whoever voluntarily obstructs a public servant in the discharge of his public functions, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to three months, or with fine which may extend to five hundred rupees, or with both.”

An Indian businessman was recently sentenced to life imprisonment for a hijack hoax on a Jet Airways’ domestic flight from Mumbai to Delhi in 2017 that resulted in an emergency landing in Ahmedabad. Birju Kishor Salla, a resident of Mumbai, was arrested and charged for posing a threat to the safety of passengers and crew on board the aircraft. He was also fined Rs 50 million ($720,000), which a special National Investigation Agency (NIA) court ruled would be given as compensation to the crew and passengers. Each pilot will get a compensation of Rs 100,000 out of the fine amount, while each member of the cabin crew will receive Rs 50,000, and each passenger will be paid Rs 25,000 for the “misery” the incident caused, according to a statement released by NIA.

The situation described in the fake hijack incident is the same as when a doctor is beaten by relatives/friends of a patient in a hospital. The safety of all patients in a hospital is at stake. And there may be more number of patients in a hospital than in an aircraft. The doctor’s role and importance is the same as that of a pilot.

The IMA has zero tolerance for patients or their relatives if they indulge in violence. The medical profession demands accountability but not at the cost of violence. A patient doesn’t have any right to attack doctors or indulge in violence at medical establishments. At the same time, doctors should not resort to violence as an answer for assault. They need to follow the principle of humanity. It is paramount for every doctor to be­come a role model in society as far as healthcare is concerned.

So, is strike the answer? In People for Better Treatment (PBT) vs West Bengal Medical Council (WBMC) & Ors on June 14, 2019, the Chief Justice of the Calcutta High Court, Thottathil B Nair Radhakrishnan, and Justice Suvra Ghosh said: “At the outset, let us record that we do not propose to proceed with the matter as an adversarial litigation. However, we need to provide appropriate push with requisite grease to ensure that the ongoing strike by a section of doctors comes to an end through governmental intervention by way of persuasion or otherwise, in accordance with law. We do so because, within the parameters of Article 21 of the Constitution of India, ‘human rights’ as understood in the civilised societies and recognised in the international domain through terms of international conventions, which bind different nations, it is the fundamental requirement that the right to health is given top priority and any need for medical help is immediately extended to any human being even if he is not a citizen.

“Therefore, we take this opportunity to state that resolution of disputes which would have arisen as a consequence of certain unfortunate events even in the hospital is not to be countered by action of eminent and well informed people like doctors by keeping away from their primary and fundamental duty to serve the people.

“Be that as it may, the State Government has also to ensure that the grievance of the doctors, particularly in relation to certain incidents which are alleged to have occurred, are addressed in accordance with law without any delay. We record the submission made by the Learned Advocate General that First Information Report has been lodged and arrests have been made insofar as the alleged incidents in which the doctors are stated to be victims. This means that the State Government has taken efforts to push the machinery in that regard. As a necessary consequence, it is definitely for the doctors to now turn themselves to the reconciliatory mode in the larger interest of the suffering people and answer their oath which they have taken when they became doctors. The great advice given through the Hippocratic Oath ought to lead them to better ways of dealing with the problems which they are faced with. The State Government shall also ensure that adequate protection is provided to the hospitals and place of work of all doctors and also such places where doctors may feel insecure in any circumstances.”

Every time there is a doctors’ strike, courts have to intervene. The solution is a central act with harsh punishment.


Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
President Elect Confederation of Medical Associations in Asia and Oceania   (CMAAO)
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Past National President IMA

Sunday, April 21, 2019

Lateral thinking: Niti Ayog to explore dentists taking up family medicine


Niti Ayog will be holding a meeting on 22nd April 2019 at 10 am with Secretary Dental Council of India and DG dental services armed forces to explore leveraging dentists to provide primary health care thereby reducing the gaps in the current shortfall of doctors in the country.

The meeting is based on the minutes of the meeting held at PM office on 9th April 2019 regarding scaling up of medical education in India when it was decided to explore the option of allowing dentists to practice family medicine/mainstream medicine following a bridge course.

This matter has been under discussion for a few years now. Government has taken the view of MCI also in this case. Things are to be seen are whether the discussion is unilateral or bilateral; means whether the discussion will also hold true for MBBS doctors starting dentistry practice with a bridge course after MBBS.

It is difficult to understand why in India we have multiple systems of medicine. Why can’t one think of all medical colleges seats to be converted into basic 3-4 years MBBS course and then later dentistry, Acupuncture, AYUSH etc. can be incorporated under mainstream specialization categories? 

The previous Medical Council of India (MCI) has opposed this. The Indian Medical Association (IMA) has also been opposing this on the grounds that the MCI Act does not approve of the same.

While doing BDS, dentists are never exposed to hospitals; there are no clinical postings for students of dentistry as for the MBBS students. A dental chair is all they need.  


Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
President Elect Confederation of Medical Associations in Asia and Oceania   (CMAAO)
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Past National President IMA

Friday, March 15, 2019

Delhi high court: Why can’t hospitals have account for CSR donations?




Abhinav Garg, Durgesh Nandan Jha | TNN | Mar 14, 2019

NEW DELHI: Why shouldn’t hospitals have a separate account to receive donations under Corporate Social Responsibility, Delhi high court sought to know on Wednesday.

Taking suo motu cognisance of a letter sent by former Indian Medical Association (IMA) president Dr KK Aggarwal, a bench of Chief Justice Rajendra Menon and Justice A J Bhambhani asked the Centre and the AAP government why the court’s 2014 guidelines in this regard were still lying in cold storage.

In its judgment, HC had then advised the government to ensure its hospitals had a separate account to receive donations under CSR from companies or from charitable entities. Converting the letter into a PIL, the bench issued a notice to the Union ministry of health and Delhi government’s health department seeking their responses.

Dr Aggarwal, president of NGO Heart Care Foundation of India, complained to HC in the letter that neither the Centre nor Delhi government had implemented the suggestions given by the court in 2014.

Pointing out that CSR initiatives, in which corporates can contribute to welfare of society either financially or through their products and services free of cost, should be welcomed by hospitals, HC had also suggested that all hospitals should have a designated officer to whom applications for assistance can be made by patients in need.

“Government hospitals could put up a list on the health department website of the drugs, implants and devices they require for EWS or BPL patients. This way, people would donate as per the needs of each hospital. This could be revised monthly. The state government may put up a list of drugs, implants and devices excluded from its budget for which donations would be welcome,” read HC’s suggestions.

The suggestions had come in HC’s judgment directing Delhi government to provide enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) free of cost at AIIMS to a poor minor boy suffering from a rare genetic disorder whenever he needed it.

At present, government hospitals provide financial aid to the poor from relief funds of the President, PM and CM, and funds from health ministry and private trusts, in addition to discretionary grants. But that is not enough, said doctors.

In 2016, AIIMS had started a unique programme — Adopt a Patient — to fill the gap between demand and supply in donations for patients. But the programme was discontinued later. “We admit about two lakh patients every year at AIIMS. Of these, 30-40% are poor and cannot pay for implants. In case of spinal injury, there have been cases where the families have abandoned patients due to lack of means to continue treatment or rehabilitate the patient at home,” the doctors had said.

(Source: TOI)


Sunday, February 17, 2013

Over 2,000 people learnt CPR in a multi-specialty camp in East Delhi



 
In a multispecialty camp organized by Heart Care Foundation of India in association with East Delhi Walkers’ Association, over 2000 people were examined by a team of medical experts led by Padmashri & Dr. BC Roy National Awardee, Dr. KK Aggarwal, President Heart Care Foundation of India and National Vice President (Elect), Indian Medical Association.

Addressing a gathering of over 2000 people, Dr. Aggarwal said that everybody should walk at least 80 minutes a day and brisk walk 80 minutes in a week. Brisk walking means walking 80 steps per minute.

Dr. Aggarwal also interacted with senior heart surgeons: Dr. Sujay Shad, Dr. Rajesh Kaushar, Dr. Mubeen Mohammad, Dr. Sandeep Singh and Dr. Baldev  Sekhon.

In the discussion, the experts said that sore throat in children should not be neglected, especially if it is without cough and nasal discharge. Streptococcal sore throat can bite the heart permanently. Timely antibiotic in these patients can prevent permanent heart damage. 



Interacting with other experts, Dr. Chanchal Pal, Dr. Shashi Bala, Dr. Prachi Garg, Dr. Pooja Garg, Dr. Varun Arya, Dr. Mini Mathur and Dr. NK Bhatia, Dr. Aggarwal said that it is better to get a swine flu as seasonal flu as mortality and morbidity is low. He said that prevention of flu involves respiratory hygiene, cough hygiene and hand hygiene. Respiratory hygiene means staying 3 feet away from the person who is coughing or sneezing. Cough etiquettes means not to cough in hands or handkerchief but on the side sleeves of the shirt. Hand hygiene means washing hands thoroughly with a soap and water after touching nasal secretion.

Dr. Sanjay Gupta, Sr. Orthopedic, Moolchand Medcity said that people who have joint knee problems should not use Indian latrines.

Dr. Sweta Gupta, infertility expert, said that today with advance techniques, it is possible to deliver a child in every family.

Dr. NK Bhatia, Sr. Transfusion Specialist, said that everybody can donate blood from the age of 16 to 65.

Dr Mini Mehta, Dr Nischal Gupta, Dr Saloni Tomar,  Dr Rashmi Bhaskar, Dr Chetali Jain, Dr  Rohit, Dr Gyanendra, Dr  Shelja and Dr Neeraj Gupta Homeopathic Cardiologists of India said that time has come for homeopathic doctors to specialize in cardiology and practice as homeopathic cardiologists.

Over 2000 people were trained on how to revive a dead person using the technique Hands Only Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation. The Foundation has trained over 30000 people in the last four months.

Saturday, January 12, 2013

Should National And State Languages Be Made Compulsory?


There are three languages a person should know in any country: A language which everybody in the world can understand, a language which everybody in the country can understand and, finally, a language which everybody in his State can understand.

I was recently in Kanyakumari where I took over as the National Vice-President (Elect) of Indian Medical Association. I met there a lot of local doctor friends. Most of them could not understand, read or speak Hindi. They were speaking either English or Tamil.

I wonder as to how people who do not know English can communicate with them. They do not know Hindi and people in north India may not know Tamil.

It is, therefore, important that Government of India should come out with a uniform policy of a national language and a state language. It should be compulsory for every person to know both national as well as sate language.

 Obviously with no exception national language can only be Hindi as it is recognized as the National language by the Government of India. English cannot be our national language but it should be learnt by everybody if you want to compete globally as practically every country has accepted English as a common language when it comes to international relations.

There is no denial that regional languages should be permitted and continued but it should not look like that you are living in a country with multiple small countries within.

Will the so called law makers or policy makers think about it or again someday some of the Supreme Court judges will have to force the Government to make uniform policy?

Dr K K Aggarwal is Padmashri and Dr B C Roy National Awardee, President Heart Care Foundation of India and National Vice President Elect IMA [ blog.kkaggarwal.com]

Saturday, September 8, 2012

Dr. KK Aggarwal Elected National Vice-President Indian Medical Association For The Year 2013-14


Dr. KK Aggarwal, President, Heart Care Foundation of India unanimously elected as National Vice President Elect of Indian Medical Association for the year 2013-14. Dr. Aggarwal is also the recipient of Padamshri and Dr. B.C. Roy National Award.

He has also served the National Indian Medical Association in the past as Finance Secretary and the Head of Research and Academic Wings. He has also been Past Vice President and President of the Delhi Medical Association and IMA New Delhi Branch and presently Chairman of the Ethical Committee of Delhi Medical Council.

He is also known for his work in the field of public health awareness. On three of the events organized by him, Union and State Governments had released national commemorative postal stamps.

Others who have been elected from Delhi were – Dr. D.R. Rai (Also National Vice President), Dr. Narender Saini, Secretary General, Dr. Ajay Gambhir, Finance Secretary.  Others elected from Delhi for various posts – Dr. Atul Arora, Dr. Nomeeta Gupta, Dr. R.K. Nathani, Dr. H.R. Saluja, Dr. K.N. Singla, Dr. Ramesh Bansal and Dr. Sanjay Sood.