Sunday, February 18, 2018

What were the mistakes in Dr Bawa Garba Case?

Dr KK Aggarwal
Recipient of Padma Shri

In 2015, Dr Bawa-Garba and the two nurses were charged with manslaughter by gross negligence following the death of Jack Adcock, a 6-year-old boy with Down syndrome in 2011.

The case against the pediatric resident was that she wasn't just clueless but grossly negligent.

Wrong working diagnosis: Missing diagnosis of sepsis

At 10:30 am, Dr Bawa-Garba assessed Jack Adcock, a 6-year old boy with Down syndrome who was referred by the general practitioner (GP) for nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea and low BP. It is not wrong to treat on the lines of hypovolemia.

She made a presumptive diagnosis of fluid depletion from gastroenteritis and administered an intravenous fluid bolus immediately and started him on maintenance fluids. She requested a chest radiograph; sent off bloods for blood count, renal function, and inflammatory markers; and drew blood gases, which showed that Jack was acidotic with a pH of 7 and a lactate of 11.

The metabolic profile confirmed her working diagnosis of shock from gastroenteritis; but, judging from the tests she ordered, pneumonia was in her differential. After the initial fluid bolus, Jack seemed to be trending in the right direction, metabolically. The repeat blood gas showed he was less acidotic, with a pH of 7.24, heading towards a normal pH of 7.4.

Delay in getting and reading chest x-ray

Fact: At 3 pm, she looked at the chest x-ray, which showed Jack had pneumonia. She prescribed antibiotics, which were given at 4 pm. The radiograph had been exposed at 12:30 pm.

Radiographs are not routinely interpreted by radiologists; there aren't enough radiologists in the NHS.

Delay in starting antibiotic

Argument: Had Jack received antibiotics within 30 minutes, rather than 6 hours, his chances of survival would have increased dramatically.

Fact: Antibiotic was given the time pneumonia was confirmed. Starting antibiotics in every case presenting in such situation may amount to misusing the antibiotics.

Also missing sepsis cannot be called manslaughter; at the most it can be an error.

Not calling her senior

Fact: At 4:30 pm, she met Dr O'Riordan, her boss, in the hospital corridor. She showed him Jack's blood gas results and explained her plan of action. Her boss did not see Jack.

When asked why he did not see Jack, Dr O'Riordan said that Dr Bawa-Garba had not asked him to; she had not impressed upon him Jack's clinical urgency.

Was the onus not on the consultant to sniff out trouble?

Guilty of homicide for mistaking normalizing pH after a fluid bolus for hypovolemic rather than septic shock

Facts: The jury heard about Jack's delayed treatment. But they did not hear about the other patients who were receiving care in the same hospital from Dr Bawa-Garba.

Jack's blood gases were deemed characteristic of sepsis. If they were so characteristic, why did Dr O'Riordan, the peripatetic consultant of the day and Dr Bawa-Garba's supervisor, not instantly diagnose sepsis when he saw the blood gases?

If a resident, who was doing the work of three registrars, can be found guilty of homicide for not understanding acid-base physiology, what does it say about the competence of her supervisor?

Failing to prevent enalapril being given 

In the ward, Jack received enalapril. Dr Bawa-Garba had not prescribed enalapril, and she clearly stated in her plan that enalapril must be stopped. Nor was enalapril given by the nursing staff—they stick to the doctor's orders. An hour after receiving enalapril, Jack had a cardiac arrest.

Fact: The drug was given by the mother and the allegation was that the team did not tell the family not to give any drug outside the hospital practice. Is it not the law?

DNR mix-up

After vigorous attempts at resuscitation, interrupted for a minute by Dr Bawa-Garba mistaking Jack for another child who was not for resuscitation, Jack was pronounced dead.

Fact: The interruption for only for a few seconds and could not have been the cause of failed CPR.

Writing honestly in the e-process log

She was honest and wrote her feelings in the e-process log which was later used against her as evidence.

After Jack's death, Dr Bawa-Garba was distraught, and her consultant encouraged her to record her failings in her electronic portfolio. Trainees are encouraged to record their mistakes. She could have, if she wanted, written about the system failures of that day. But that would have been making excuses, and you don't stick around in a field like pediatrics if you're the sort who points fingers at others. But was this not her mistake?

The most merciless expert witness was none other than Dr Bawa-Garba herself. Her electronic portfolio became her confession. She erred because she had confessed to erring.

Was it the failure of a doctor?

The trust led an internal inquiry that identified several system issues that contributed to Jack's death. Medical errors can be caused by system issues and physician factors. The American patient safety movement has taken the high road and placed the blame for medical errors on systems. The Tort system targets both individuals and systems. The truth is that both can contribute.

Not raising an alarm on inadequate staff and system failures

Dr Bawa-Garba's supervisor, Dr O'Riordan, was not in the hospital but teaching in a nearby city.

Dr Bawa-Garba's colleagues (i.e., other registrars) were also away on educational leave. Normally, a registrar each is assigned to cover the wards, the emergency department, and the Children's Assessment Unit (CAU).

On that day, Dr Bawa-Garba covered all three. She was new to the hospital but with no formal induction (i.e., no explanation where things are and how stuff gets done in the hospital). She was expected to get along with the call and find her way around the hospital.

Registrars are the principle decision-makers in hospitals; they function as both a senior resident and an attending.

Should she have raised an alarm and wrote about the deficiencies in the system?




Dr KK Aggarwal


Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA



Saturday, February 17, 2018

Dr Bawa Garba Case: Indian doctors need immunity while reporting adverse events

Dr KK Aggarwal
Recipient of Padma Shri

The historical manslaughter conviction of a UK doctor related to a case in which a six-year-old boy died at Leicester Royal Infirmary in 2011 that found her guilty of manslaughter by gross negligence in 2015, has opened a large number of issues of importance to Indian medical practice.

One of the issues of concern is the handling of Dr Bawa-Garba's case linked to reflective writing from her e-portfolio, which was reported to have been used in evidence. Though her medical defence organization has made clear that information from the e-portfolio was not used but notes made by her duty consultant on a meeting with Dr Bawa-Garba after the event to discuss and learn from it, formed part of his witness statement. 

In UK, GMC requires that all doctors in training must write reflections, especially when there are things that do not go well. This is an essential part of training and is needed to progress through a postgraduate training program. A failure to record reflections honestly could give rise to a referral to the GMC. It’s like the log book in DNB training in India.

It is an unwritten law that a doctor should avoid using patients’ names or initials, dates of birth, or “any unique condition or circumstance of that patient in a reflective log, but it is often ignored.

Also, during writing doctors should “try not to be judgmental” or say “I made a mistake, I made an error, I got things wrong”, but it’s also very important not to say in any way “I was negligent.”

Doctor’s reflections are potentially disclosable to courts, tribunals and coroners. The Crown Prosecution Service initially decided not to charge Bawa-Garba in 2012, but the decision was reviewed after the coroner’s inquest into Jack’s death and she was charged in 2014.

This issue now also has generated safety concerns. Patient safety is going to be affected if the medical profession is unable to reflect honestly and openly on mistakes for fear of being left open to prosecution; though reflective writing is not a norm in India.

The issue has raised concerns in reporting in AEFI (Adverse events following Immunization), PvPI (Pharmaco Vigilance Program of India) and Sentinel Events reporting under NABH accreditation. Unless a legal immunity is provided, based on Dr Bawa case, doctors may withhold many such reporting.

It is true that in PvPI the submitted ADR report does not have any legal implication on the reporters. Also, the patients’ identities are held in strict confidence and protected to the fullest extent. But courts can ask for the reports. There is no legal immunity for the reporting.

MCI Code of Ethics Regulations 7.14 The registered medical practitioner shall not disclose the secrets of a patient that have been learnt in the exercise of his / her profession except –
  1. in a court of law under orders of the Presiding Judge;
  2. in circumstances where there is a serious and identified risk to a specific person and / or community; and
  3. notifiable diseases.

Dr KK Aggarwal


Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India

Immediate Past National President IMA

Friday, February 16, 2018

Dr Bawa-Garba Case will increase antibiotic misuse

Dr KK Aggarwal
Recipient of Padma Shri

“A six year old boy is admitted to the Children’s Assessment Unit (CAU) at Leicester Royal Infirmary following a referral from his GP. Jack Adcock, who had Down's syndrome and a known heart condition, had been suffering from diarrhea, vomiting and had difficulty breathing.

Dr Hadiza Bawa-Garba was a specialist registrar in year six of her postgraduate training (ST6) with an 'impeccable' record. She had recently returned from maternity leave and this was her first shift in an acute setting. She was the most senior doctor covering the CAU, the emergency department and the ward CAU that day. She saw Jack at about 10.30am. Jack was receiving supplementary oxygen and Dr Bawa-Garba prescribed a fluid bolus and arranged for blood tests and a chest x-ray. At 10.44am the first blood gas test was available and showed a worryingly high lactate reading. The x-ray became available from around 12.30pm and showed evidence of a chest infection.

Dr Bawa-Garba was heavily involved in treating other children between 12-3pm, including a baby that needed a lumbar puncture. At 3pm Dr Bawa-Garba reviewed Jack's X-ray (she was not informed before then that it was available) and prescribed a dose of antibiotics immediately, which Jack received an hour later from the nurses.
A failure in the hospital's electronic computer system that day meant that although she had ordered blood tests at about 10.45am, Dr Bawa-Garba did not receive them until about 4.15pm. It also meant her senior house officer was unavailable.

During a handover meeting with a consultant, which took place about 4.30pm, Dr Bawa-Garba raised the high level of CRP in Jack's blood test results and a diagnosis of pneumonia, but she did not ask the consultant to review the patient. She said Jack had been much improved and was bouncing about. At 6.30 pm, she spoke to the consultant a second time, but again did not raise any concerns.

When she wrote up the initial notes, she did not specify that Jack’s enalapril (for his heart condition) should be discontinued. Jack was subsequently given his evening dose of enalapril by his mother after he was transferred to the ward around 7pm.

At 8pm a ‘crash call’ went out and Dr Bawa-Garba was one of the doctors who responded to it. On entering the room she mistakenly confused Jack with another patient and called off the resuscitation. Her mistake was identified within 30 seconds to two minutes and resuscitation continued. This hiatus did not contribute to Jack’s death, as his condition was already too far advanced. At 9.20pm, Jack died.

November 2, 2015: Portuguese agency nurse, 47-year-old Isabel Amaro, of Manchester is given a two-year suspended jail sentence for manslaughter on the grounds of gross negligence.

November 4, 2015: At Nottingham Crown Court, Dr Bawa-Garba is convicted of manslaughter on the grounds of gross negligence.

December 14, 2015: Dr Bawa-Garba is given a 24 month suspended sentence.

December 8, 2016: Dr Bawa-Garba's appeal against her sentence is quashed at the Court of Appeal.

June 13, 2017: The Medical Practitioners Tribunal service says Dr Bawa-Garba should be suspended for 12 months and rejects an application from the GMC to strike her off the register. It says: ‘In the circumstances of this case, balancing the mitigating and aggravating factors, the tribunal concluded that erasure would be disproportionate.’

December 8, 2017: GMC takes the MPTS to the High Court and argues its own tribunal was 'wrong' to allow Dr Bawa-Garba to continue to practice.

January 25, 2018: The GMC successfully appeals at the High Court bid to have the MPTS decision overruled, leading to Dr Bawa-Garba being struck off the medical register. Lord Justice Ouseley says: 'The Tribunal did not respect the verdict of the jury as it should have. In fact, it reached its own and less severe view of the degree of Dr Bawa-Garba’s personal culpability.’ Health secretary Jeremy Hunt says that he is 'deeply concerned' about its implications.

January 26, 2018: Prominent GPs tell Pulse that the ruling raises serious questions about how doctor's reflections are used and recorded, and that new guidance is now needed urgently.

January 30, 2018: An influential international doctors group accuses the GMC of treating black and minority ethnic doctors ‘differently and harshly’, following the High Court case.

January 31, 2018: Dr Bawa-Garba’s defence body releases a statement saying e-portfolio reflections were not used against her in court, despite ‘wide misreporting’ that they were. But Pulse uncovers that her reflections were used in court, from a document submitted as evidence by the on-call consultant on the day.

February 7, 2018: Following a crowd funding campaign, which raised over £335,000, Dr Bawa-Garba decides to appeal the ruling, and considers appealing the manslaughter conviction from 2015.

February 12, 2018: The GMC refutes claims that there was discrimination in its decision to launch a High Court bid. In response to an open letter from the British Association of Physicians of Indian Origin (BAPIO), the GMC said the accusations were ‘troubling and without merit’.” [From media reports]

Dr KK: This is a historic case and will be remembered in the history of medical profession. We also must react, or this will lead to unnecessary antibiotics. In history, no case has been filed for giving an antibiotic, but all cases filed are due to delay in instituting an antibiotic, as also happened in this case. One of the experts in this case said in the court if antibiotics were given at admission the child would not have died.


Dr KK Aggarwal


Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA

Thursday, February 15, 2018

Should we compare ourselves with CAs, Lawyers and Architects?


    
Dr K K Aggarwal

Recipient of Padma Shri

Quiet often we argue that medical profession cannot be treated in isolation.

All other professions, be it law, CA, sportspersons, actors, hotels, musicians, social lecturers, astrologers may charge recklessly without doing as much, even one-tenth of doctors, with sincerity and seriousness.

But remember we are different.

We, and not they, are considered next to God. We, and not they, are social business houses.

We, and not they, are given permission to suffix Dr. before their names.

We, and not they, are bound by professional ethics.

MCI Code of Ethics Regulations 6.3 Running an open shop (Dispensing of Drugs and Appliances by Physicians): “A physician should not run an open shop for sale of medicine for dispensing prescriptions prescribed by doctors other than himself or for sale of medical or surgical appliances. It is not unethical for a physician to prescribe or supply drugs, remedies or appliances as long as there is no exploitation of the patient. Drugs prescribed by a physician or brought from the market for a patient should explicitly state the proprietary formulae as well as generic name of the drug.”

Supreme Court of India: Samira Kohli vs Dr. Prabha Manchanda & Anr on 16 January, 2008: “28. But unfortunately not all doctors in government hospitals are paragons of service, nor fortunately, all private hospitals/doctors are commercial minded. There are many a doctor in government hospitals who do not care about patients and unscrupulously insist upon 'unofficial' payment for free treatment or insist upon private consultations. On the other hand, many private hospitals and Doctors give the best of treatment without exploitation, at a reasonable cost, charging a fee, which is reasonable recompense for the service rendered.

Of course, some doctors, both in private practice or in government service, look at patients not as persons who should be relieved from pain and suffering by prompt and proper treatment at an affordable cost, but as potential income-providers/ customers who can be exploited by prolonged or radical diagnostic and treatment procedures. It is this minority who bring a bad name to the entire profession.”

The word exploitation in the first reference and reasonable in the second reference bind us different from other professions.

Opinions may differ but my personal opinion is that for medical professionals, earning is a byproduct and not the first objective.



Dr KK Aggarwal


Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA


Wednesday, February 14, 2018

The 7-year itch: Redefining a relationship

Boy meets girl…girl meets boy…sparks fly and they live happily ever after. This is the classic notion of romantic love, but which happens only in fairy tales.

Real life relationships don’t just happen. Every relationship evolves over time and has to work its way through five stages before it settles down to last a lifetime. These five stages, in order of their appearance, are:

1.    Euphoria
2.    Reaction
3.    Adjustment
4.    Liking
5.    Love

The first phase in any relationship is that of euphoria. Everything appears rosy in this first flush of love. All flaws are overlooked and the relationship is wonderful and easy. Both partners feel great, light and on the air. The amphetamine-like substance called phenyl-ethylamine is the neuromodulator in this phase. 

The excitement soon starts wearing off and then reality hits. This is the phase of reaction wherein both partners start reacting to each other’s behavior and lifestyle. Disillusionment sets in. Arguments begin to occur. It is during this stage that most break-ups occur. The reactions are based on release of adrenaline and noradrenaline.

The phase of reaction is dependent on the changes in our needs. Every person has five types of needs and they are Physical, Mental, Intellectual, Egoistic and Spiritual Needs. Physical needs are needs for physical and sexual intimacy; mental needs are to share one’s emotions and need for a shoulder when in the need of a cry; intellectual needs are the needs to discuss about future, decision making etc.; egoistic needs are the needs to acquire power and spiritual needs are the needs to acquire inner happiness.  Husbands and wives who fulfil all the above needs of each other are called “made for each other”.

Next is the phase of adjustment. The two partners start adjusting to reality and start accepting each other’s differences. They are able to overcome the power struggle in the relationship.

Both phases of reaction and adjustment may carry on for up to 7 years. During this period, both partners are compelled to stay with each other and they start adjusting to each other’s needs and lifestyle. It is not an easy time for many. This is also the time when a relationship is redefined.

Liking develops by the 7th year. This is the phase when the two partners learn to trust each other and start feeling dependent on each other. They are able to deal with and resolve their differences bringing to an end all the misunderstandings that have so far plagued their relationship. 

The last phase is phase of love or soul-to-soul relationship ‘soul mate’. This phase may start decades after the marriage and is the basis of 25th, 50th & 75th marriage anniversary. People in this phase of marriage are totally dependent on each other and cannot face separation. If one person dies, the other may go into depression and also die within a short period of time. The neurochemicals involved in this phase are endorphins.

These five stages apply to not just romantic love, but also to every relationship, be it with your job, friends, coworkers etc. It is unconditional love.

Which stage are you in your relationship?


Dr KK Aggarwal


Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India

Immediate Past National President IMA

Tuesday, February 13, 2018

If we don’t self-regulate, then the govt. will



There has always been a dispute whether healthcare is a commercial business or a social business. The first step in regulation of the medical profession was taken when the medical profession was brought under the Consumer Protection Act (CPA). Consequently, any medical service provided to the patient in the form of consultation, diagnosis and treatment came to be under the ambit of ‘service’ as defined in the CPA.

In several of its judgements, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has stated that costs/charges in the medical profession must be reasonable. In the matter of Samira Kohli vs Dr. Prabha Manchanda & Anr on 16 January, 2008, the Apex Court said, “28. But unfortunately not all doctors in government hospitals are paragons of service, nor fortunately, all private hospitals/doctors are commercial minded. There are many a doctor in government hospitals who do not care about patients and unscrupulously insist upon 'unofficial' payment for free treatment or insist upon private consultations. On the other hand, many private hospitals and Doctors give the best of treatment without exploitation, at a reasonable cost, charging a fee, which is reasonable recompense for the service rendered. Of course, some doctors, both in private practice or in government service, look at patients not as persons who should be relieved from pain and suffering by prompt and proper treatment at an affordable cost, but as potential income-providers/ customers who can be exploited by prolonged or radical diagnostic and treatment procedures. It is this minority who bring a bad name to the entire profession.”

The word to be taken note of here is “exploitation”. You cannot charge more in an emergency. If you do, this may mean that you are exploiting the patient.

Earning a profit is required for sustenance. But should this justify profiteering? A very fine line separates the two, which must never be crossed.

The word “reasonable” needs to be defined. The govt. always wanted to cap pricing in the medical profession. Towards this end, the govt. introduced the Clinical Establishments Act (CEA) to regulate prices in health care, which was opposed by the IMA.

The govt. is now trying to control prices via TPA, CGHS, state government health scheme and now through the newly launched “National Health Protection Scheme” under the Ayushman Bharat initiative announced in the Budget on Feb.1, 2018. The National Health Protection Scheme will provide coverage of Rs 5 lakh rupees per family per year for secondary and tertiary hospitalization, but only under the ‘general ward’ category to about 50 crore beneficiaries. This scheme may be taken advantage of or exploited.

This means that the govt. may cap the prices for each procedure as it did under the Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY), a health insurance scheme for the Below Poverty line (BPL) families, which provided a coverage of Rs 30, 000/- per annum to beneficiaries on a family floater basis. Under this scheme, the govt. has framed indicative package rates for several interventions or procedures.

The only way health sector can be controlled is by way of re-imbursement.   Just as the HMOs have controlled healthcare costs in the US, insurance companies in India too may control pricing in India.

Two types of costs may be worked out; one, a reasonable’ cost, one which could be covered under the ‘general ward’ category as directed by the govt. and the other a ‘private’ cost, which is not capped and allows charging as per the paying capacity of the patient.

If we don’t self-regulate, then the govt. will. Then we may have no choice but to comply with the price cap that has been put by the govt.

Dr KK Aggarwal


Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India

Immediate Past National President IMA

Tuesday, January 9, 2018

H3N2 Aussies Flu, a near epidemic in Australia, UK and USA: H1N1 in Rajasthan India

H3N2 Aussies Flu, a near epidemic in Australia, UK and USA
H1N1 in Rajasthan India

The flu is rapidly spreading across the US, UK and Australia.

Not only did it start early, but it seemed to occur all over the country more or less simultaneously.
The predominant flu strain is H3N2. Vaccine effectiveness typically ranges from 40 to 60 percent in a good year. Preliminary estimates from last year show the vaccine was 40 percent effective in the U.S., similar to 2014-2015. But concerns have been raised about this year’s vaccine after an editorial published in the New England Journal of Medicine last Thursday said it was only 10 percent effective against H3N2 in Australia.

Additionally, years in which H3N2 is the predominant influenza strain tend to have higher death rates, with approximately 20,000 deaths in the 2012-2013 and 2014-2015 seasons when H3N2 predominated.

Good news is that H3N2 flu is quite susceptible to the available flu medications, like Tamiflu, also known as oseltamivir. Remember, it is most helpful if taken within 48 hours of the start of the flu. It can take up to two weeks for the body to build up defences against the virus.

It is especially important for pregnant women to get the vaccine. There is dual benefit for the pregnant woman to get vaccinated. Not only will she get protection, but she’ll also pass those antibodies along to her infant, which will protect them for the first 6 months of life when the infant is too young to get the vaccine. And the vaccine is safe for pregnant women and the fetus.

For those who contract the flu, it could make symptoms less severe. Next, make sure to wash hands carefully to limit the spread of the virus and try to avoid close contact with sick people.

People who get sick should also keep up with fluids — and seek medical attention if they start to feel worse or develop shortness of breath, worsening congestion or cough.

Public Health Concerns

1.       Trace the first case of H3N2 in India
2.       High risk people to consider vaccinations
3.       Do not allow any person suffering from flu to enter public places
4.       Give compulsory off to people suffering from flu

5.       Learn cough etiquettes and respiratory hygiene