Saturday, April 14, 2018

Patients have the right to know the credentials of the treating doctor



A colleague of mine in the US needed a hip replacement surgery to be done via minimally invasive technique. He found that there is a learning curve for hip replacement surgery, which stipulates a minimum 100 patients to become an expert in this surgery. He identified a surgeon, who had done 92 such surgeries and waited for him to reach the figure of 100. He then underwent the surgery in the US.

A doctor’s wife needed a surgical intervention for acoustic neuroma. Injury to the facial nerve during surgery is still a major concern. The surgeons were asked directly about the number of such cases operated by them and their success rates in facial nerve preservation. One surgeon in the US said that he had no facial nerve damage in his last 800 cases. The patient was successfully operated in the US without any complications.

This is the latest trend and is a requirement for medical treatment.

There are four types of patients: Ignorant, Informed, Empowered and Enlightened. Most patients today are empowered and enlightened and want the best of care. Every patient has the right to know the academic background of the treating doctor, skill training, the number of similar procedures or cases performed, and disclose success rates and complication rates, and the ability of the doctor to anticipate and manage complications quickly including awards and honors received, infrastructure available, competency of the juniors and associated staff. Any conflict/s of interest must also be disclosed.

In this digital age, this information should be available on websites of the doctor/healthcare establishment. Any false claim can lead to legal implications.

Regulation 1.4.2 of MCI Code of Ethics Regulations allows doctors to suffix recognized medical degrees or certificates/diplomas and memberships/honours which confer professional knowledge or recognizes any exemplary qualification/achievement to their names.

Every patient has the right to know the credentials of the treating doctor. Recognizing this, recently the Chennai High Court has suggested to the MCI to display number of attempts by doctors in examinations in the website and also in the hospital/clinic concerned so that patients would know the doctor’s performance. Justice S Vaidyanathan in support of his observation said the MCI will have to take a decision and ensure that the number of attempts made by doctors will have to be displayed in the website and also in the hospital/clinic concerned, in order to enable patients to know performance of the doctor as a student.


Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA

Friday, April 13, 2018

Suspected chemical attack in Syria



Key principles in management of exposure to chemical warfare agents

Syria has been in the midst of a civil war for many years now. Most recently, in a suspected chemical attack, around 500 patients presented to health facilities exhibiting signs and symptoms consistent with exposure to toxic chemicals during the shelling of Douma on Saturday, said the WHO. All affected people showed signs of severe irritation of mucous membranes, respiratory failure and disruption to central nervous systems. More than 70 people sheltering in basements have reportedly died, with 43 of those deaths related to symptoms consistent with exposure to highly toxic chemicals.

WHO has demanded immediate unhindered access to the area to provide care to those affected, to assess the health impact and also to deliver a comprehensive public health response.

Since 2012 there have been sporadic reports of chemical events in Syria. And, the WHO has been engaged in public health preparedness for chemical weapons use in Syria since then.

The Chemical Weapons Convention (CWC) applies the term chemical weapon to any toxic chemical or its precursor that can cause death, injury, temporary incapacitation or sensory irritation through its chemical action. 

Together with nuclear and biological agents, chemical weapons constitute the weapons of mass destruction.

Any use of chemical weapons to cause harm is illegal under international law. But, the possibility of their use is far from remote. So it is important to know about chemical warfare agents.

Based on their mode of action i.e. the route of penetration and their effect on the human body, chemical weapons can be categorized as:

·         Pulmonary “choking” agents (chlorine or phosgene)
·         “Blood” agents (cyanide compounds)
·         Vesicants “blister" agents (sulfur mustard, nitrogen mustard and lewisite)
·         Nerve agents (sarin, soman, VX)
·         Incapacitating agents (BZ, an anticholinergic agent)

Riot-control agents e.g. OC (oleoresin capsicum) and CS (o-chlorobenzylidene malononitrile) are also considered as chemical weapon agents by the CWC.

The sudden onset of symptoms with common clinical findings among several patients within a short period of time - ranging from minutes to hours - should raise the suspicion of use of chemical agents. The effects of biological agents become apparent after many hours to weeks.  

It may be possible to identify the chemical agent used by its odor and color. Chlorine is a yellow-green gas with a characteristic chlorine odor, whereas phosgene is a colorless gas or white cloud with odor of newly mown or musty hay, grass, or corn. Cyanide has the smell of bitter almonds. A yellow-brown vapour or liquid that smells like onions or garlic is a mustard agent. Tabun, Sarin and Soman, the nerve agents are colorless and tasteless with a slight fruity odor.

Signs of upper airway (central compartment) irritation are consistent with type I (hydrogen chloride or hydrogen fluoride) or combination (chlorine) pulmonary agent exposure. On the other hand, signs of pulmonary edema (peripheral compartment) suggest type II pulmonary agent exposure (phosgene).

Protection of First responders and First receivers with personal protection equipment, patient triage for treatment, including administration of specific antidote at the site of the incident “hot zone” and in the hospital, decontamination, and transport to medical care facility, spot decontamination and field decontamination are key principles in the initial management of patients exposed to chemical warfare agents.

The ‘ABCDE’ of management in the event of a chemical agent exposure can be summarized as below:

·         Airway: Maintain an open airway.
·         Breathing: Administer oxygen for respiratory distress; ventilate (bag-mask) and intubate, if indicated.
·         Circulation: Maintain circulation
·         Decontamination: Immediate simultaneously with triage and the provision of lifesaving interventions; ‘wet’ (using water) or ‘dry’ (removing clothes and using absorbent materials); local or spot decontamination of any suspicious liquid on the skin or in wounds
·         Drugs: Administration of specific antidotes at the site (via autoinjector before establishing IVaccess) and in the hospital.
·         Exposure: Dispose of the contaminated clothing as chemical waste safely; avoid hypothermia, especially in infants, children, and the elderly.



Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA

Thursday, April 12, 2018

How to handle negative press



No marketing strategy works as best as ‘word of mouth’ in the health sector, even in this digital age. Patients still rely on recommendations from friends and relatives when choosing a doctor or hospital. While you may enjoy a stellar reputation, negative or unfavorable publicity is to be expected from time to time. It’s not all rosy all the time. However, a negative word of mouth or a negative story in the press can be nightmarish for the doctor and the healthcare establishment as it can destroy their credibility.

This crisis too can be managed…negative press can be dealt with and the damage minimized.

·         If there is bad press, don’t hide or ignore it, instead confront it. While “silence is golden”, remaining silent may be interpreted as admission of guilt.
·         Don’t panic; keep a cool head. Don’t react, but respond.
·         Present your version of the story rationally, supported by facts, to the newspaper or the media, which has carried the story. You have a right to reply if you think that the story reported is biased or factually inaccurate.
·         Never talk ‘off the record’.
·         Take help from your legal team and PR professionals.
·         The welfare of patients is the foremost for doctors. A negative story would bring forth several queries not only from other interested journalists/press but also patients and their families, perhaps even your employees. They need assurance. Try to anticipate questions and be ready with clear and concise answers… “No comment” may not be the right response as it may give the impression that you are being defensive.
·         Be empathetic.
·         A lawsuit should be the last resort.
·         The usual approach in case of a negative story is to deny and defend. Instead, introspect if there could be some truth in it. This could be just the impetus to shake off complacency and turn it into an opportunity for improvement.
·         If you have made a mistake, then admit it and apologize. You should not only say sorry, but you should also mean it. It may help restore the goodwill and trust that has been lost. An insincere apology may only complicate matters further.
·         Above all, pre-empt a potential crisis and take timely steps to prevent it.

Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA
                                                     

Wednesday, April 11, 2018

Verify health information on Twitter before using it in daily practice




Advances in medicine have added greatly to the therapeutic armamentarium of the doctor. There are several options that a doctor can choose from unlike the yesteryears. Similar is the case with diagnostic options. In this age of evidence-based medicine, doctors need to stay updated with current advances in medicine in general including their specialties in order to make the best decision for their patients. Traditionally, it used to be print medical journals, which may yet be the source of information for many doctors. But, the internet and the advent of social media, especially Twitter, have changed the way we communicate today. The reach of social media is phenomenal.

Healthcare professionals use Twitter not only to connect with their colleagues, but also as a quick resource to access new information and events, often ‘real time’ i.e. as they are happening, particularly when time is of the essence.

While better connectivity has contributed immensely to the practice of medicine by disseminating knowledge, on the flip side of it, sifting out the valid from the invalid on the internet is no simple task.

There is no denying that Twitter can gain you the latest information in the form of a practice changing update, breaking news, conference updates or what are the most currently discussed ‘trending’ topics. You can also be a part of the ‘Twitter discussions’. But it is important to examine the credibility of the tweet, whether the content posted is evidence-based or is a personal opinion. The information in the permitted 140-280 characters usually may be the interpretation of that particular Twitter account holder. Always go the main article and try to verify the source. Review the information for yourself, before you decide to use it in your daily practice.


Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA
                                                     

Tuesday, April 10, 2018

Hospital to charge medical representatives for visits


Medica Superspecialty Hospital in Kolkata has announced a levy of charges on medical representatives visiting its facility. The hospital has restricted the visit of a medical representative to only one day a week against a charge of Rs 350/- for three hours. Beyond this, Rs 100 per hour will be levied. A hospital in Delhi is already doing this, charging Rs 5000 per month.

The decision was aimed at discouraging MRs from visiting the hospital. The plea given is that the hospital wants to promote generic drugs.

eMedinews does not agree with this. It’s like taking away the freedom of the doctors. The knowledge about drug updates, side effects and new drug interventions that the medical representative shares is important for doctors, especially when there is no Govt. system in place by which information about banned drugs, introduction of new drugs or introduction of new equipment reaches every doctor.

MCI ethics regulation 6.8 allows a doctor to associate with pharma industry, though with some riders as follows:

“g) Affiliation:- A medical practitioner may work for pharmaceutical and allied healthcare industries in advisory capacities, as consultants, as researchers, as treating doctors or in any other professional capacity. In doing so, a medical practitioner shall always:-
(i) Ensure that his professional integrity and freedom are maintained.
(ii) Ensure that patients interest are not compromised in any way.
(iii) Ensure that such affiliations are within the law.
(iv) Ensure that such affiliations/ employments are fully transparent and disclosed.”


The MCI Ethics code does not restrict an ethical interaction between a doctor and a medical representative. The MCI Ethics Code also does not restrict academic gifts, CDs, scientific updates from pharma representatives as long as the ‘per time’ cost is less than 1000/-. Regulation 6.8.1 a has defined punishment for Gifts more than Rs. 1,000/- up to Rs. 5,000/- as ‘censure’.

Monday, April 9, 2018

Handling of food and money must be physically separated



Vide a notification File No. 1/Stds/SP(L&C/A)/Advisories/FSSAI dated March 28, 2018, the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) has cautioned that “cross contamination from currency is a risk to human health leading to a wide variety of diseases including food poisoning, skin, respiratory and intestinal infections”.

Currency notes and coins become contaminated with harmful microorganisms when they are handled with unclean and soiled hands, use of saliva during counting of notes and/or stored under unhygienic conditions.

The notification further recommends that food handlers, food sellers and others should avoid handling currency and food simultaneously. Also,

·         Gloves must be worn when handling food
·         Bare hands to be used for handling currency
·         Hands must be thoroughly washed after handling money and before touching food and vice versa
·         Handling of food and money must be physically separated

Several studies have shown notes and coins as potential source of infection. Banknotes recovered from hospitals may be highly contaminated by Staphylococcus aureus, while, Salmonella, Escherichia coli and S. aureus are commonly isolated from banknotes from food outlets.Influenza virus, Norovirus, Rhinovirus, hepatitis A virus, and Rotavirus can be transmitted through hand contact (Future Microbiol. 2014;9(2):249-61). Moreover, they may also harbor antibiotic-resistant bacteria, such as MRSA and cause them to spread further.

Antibiotic resistance is escalating and making it difficult to treat infections. It prolongs hospitalization, increases cost of treatment and mortality. Antibiotic resistance can affect individuals of any age, even children.

With no new antibiotics on the horizon, the situation may revert to a ‘pre-antibiotic era’ as the WHO has also warned, unless steps are taken urgently to curb this public health danger. UK public health experts are investigating a man infected with a multidrug-resistant form of gonorrhea that is believed to be the first case to display high-level resistance to the recommended first-line treatments and to most other commonly used antibiotics.

Hand hygiene is the simplest and also the most economical way to prevent transmission of harmful microorganisms and control spread of infection. The catch phrase is "before and after", which means, one should wash hands before and after eating food, before and after touching any infected material, before and after seeing a patient or before and after normal evacuation of stool in the morning.

Just as the currency exchanges hands, so does the disease …This reiterates the need for hand washing before and after handling currency.

Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA

Sunday, April 8, 2018

Apology works




AIIMS New Delhi, a premier institute of the country, has tendered an apology to a patient who underwent a wrong procedure.

The written apology was sent to the 30-year-old patient, a resident of Bihar, and her husband was contacted with an offer for additional treatment. Allegedly, an arteriovenous fistula was made in the patient who did not have any kidney-related illness and instead was seeking treatment for pain in abdomen. AV fistula is created surgically in chronic kidney disease patients undergoing dialysis. Documents were allegedly tampered with to cover up the medical negligence.

Primum non nocere i.e. “first (above all) do no harm” is the cardinal principle that guides the ethics of practice of medicine. From it is derived the principle of non maleficence (do no harm) and its natural corollary, the principle of beneficence (do good).

Doctors never harm a patient intentionally. But sometimes, errors do happen even with all precautions.

In the event of any unanticipated adverse incident or outcome that may cause harm to the patient, patients now want answers. They can no longer be pacified with medical jargon; instead, they want to know the facts of the matter and the circumstances leading to it. They also want to know if a medical error could have caused the adverse outcome and want doctors and establishments to apologize to them, if the error was ‘avoidable’.

Non disclosure or ‘hushing up’ of errors increases feelings of anger and blame in the patients and creates distrust between the doctor and patient. And the aftermath is well-familiar to us all – negligence lawsuits against doctors and hospitals or angry relatives and friends ransacking the hospital or assaulting the doctor and other staff.

Apologize to the patient in such situations…an apology works.

While an apology does not undo the damage caused, it can alleviate the resulting feelings of anger and distrust. An apology can be either with admission of guilt or without admission of guilt.

But doctors find it difficult to admit to a mistake. Doctors are apprehensive - quite rightly so, given the absence of apology laws in the country - that apologizing for a mistake can be considered an ‘admission of guilt’ and used as evidence in courts of law.

Some states in the US have apology laws that protect an apology from being admissible as evidence in courts of law in medical negligence cases

While saying sorry for any wrong done is an immediate instinct of human nature, on the other hand, the fear of ensuing litigation prevents doctors from admitting to their mistakes. It is a classic ‘Catch-22’ situation because the outcome may anyway be a medical malpractice claim now or at a later date, when the mistake may be discovered.

Saying “I/We have made a mistake” and acknowledging that mistake with an apology takes lot of courage. But it goes a long way in restoring trust between the doctor and the patient and may defuse a situation that is just ready to explode.

Opinion 8.121 of the American Medical Association (AMA) Code of Medical Ethics says “Physicians must offer professional and compassionate concern toward patients who have been harmed, regardless of whether the harm was caused by a health care error. An expression of concern need not be an admission of responsibility. When patient harm has been caused by an error, physicians should offer a general explanation regarding the nature of the error and the measures being taken to prevent similar occurrences in the future. Such communication is fundamental to the trust that underlies the patient-physician relationship, and may help reduce the risk of liability.”

The Joint Commission standard also says, “Patients and, when appropriate, their families are informed about the outcomes of care, including unanticipated outcomes” (RI. 1.2.2).

Related links

·           Medical Errors: “I am sorry” http://drkkaggarwal.blogspot.in/2017/09/medical-errors-i-am-sorry.html
·           The spiritual prescription: "I am sorry" http://issue.emedinews.in/archive/13_6_14.html


Dr KK Aggarwal
Padma Shri Awardee
Vice President CMAAO
Group Editor-in-Chief IJCP Publications
President Heart Care Foundation of India
Immediate Past National President IMA